Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pete, that is absolute *******s. Before I retired, BIPs policy were part of my Division. I worked closely with my veterinary colleagues who were conducting the checks at the BIPs. After some blips at the beginning of 2021, things settled down and are running smoothly ever since. The biggest delays were at Dover which has meant that much more exporters are now shipping directly to France rather than the previous favourite Landbridge through GB

We had (presumably still have) regular meetings with DEFRA and DAER (NI) to make sure there was minimum delay.

700 pages??? Latin???? FFS.

I merely repeated what was stated in the HoC today…..
 
Marks & Spencer Chairman….

”Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said it was “very, very tough” to meet current requirements.

“At the moment, wagons arriving in the ROI have to carry 700 pages of documentation. It takes about eight hours to prepare the documentation. Some of the descriptors, particularly of animal products, have to be in Latin. It has to be in a certain typeface. We employ 13 vets in Motherwell to prepare it all…

Mr Norman, who also said the protocol costs “30% more driver time”, claimed the EU is “looking for us to impose comparable controls for Northern Ireland” and warned this would stop the movement of goods altogether in some instances.”

Lunacy, pure unadulterated Lunacy….

All that tells me is that it was lunacy to actually leave the EU. Look at that simple example of the burden and cost placed on a UK business exporting to the EU i.e. the ROI. Staying in the free market none of that was necessary. Its like chopping your hand off, then complaining that you cant wear gloves.
 
I merely repeated what was stated in the HoC today…..
Ahh. Since when did Latin become an official and compulsory language of the EU?

As for 700 pages - that is a ridiculous, gross exaggeration. It is a pain for our officials alright but after some early hiccups, it has been working very well for the past 12 months
 
Ok found it.


The Latin refers to species of plants and flowers I would think unless he has a problem with ovine, bovine, porcine, equine as English language descriptions of meat.

My experience is in meat and animal health. I cannot speak on requirements for import of plant species but I would be shocked at 700 pages - I think we might have heard about this before now
 
Ok found it.


The Latin refers to species of plants and flowers I would think unless he has a problem with ovine, bovine, porcine, equine as English language descriptions of meat.

My experience is in meat and animal health. I cannot speak on requirements for import of plant species but I would be shocked at 700 pages - I think we might have heard about this before now
Ah, C'mon now. 700 pages isn't bad. GoT has done 5432 pages just talking about it! 700 is for lightweights!
 
Ahh. Since when did Latin become an official and compulsory language of the EU?

As for 700 pages - that is a ridiculous, gross exaggeration. It is a pain for our officials alright but after some early hiccups, it has been working very well for the past 12 months

I have no idea. I just repeated what was spoken in the HoC….
 
It was one of the Irish MP’s, I honestly can’t remember his name, probably DUP but I don’t know. I looked up the detail afterwards and there was also an article about the M&S Chairman saying what he did…..

Cheers mate - mind you a DUP MP would not thank you for calling them an Irish MP :cool: Have a look at the Newsletter article in my earlier post.
 
All that tells me is that it was lunacy to actually leave the EU. Look at that simple example of the burden and cost placed on a UK business exporting to the EU i.e. the ROI. Staying in the free market none of that was necessary. Its like chopping your hand off, then complaining that you cant wear gloves.

Fair comment, except why do the EU do it. It kills trade with Africa and S America and has no benefit for consumers. It’s protectionist and nothing else……
 
This from the DAFM part of the Irish Government website. I can't see any of this requiring 7 pages never mind 700!!


This for plant imports - a phytosanitary cert is usually one or two pages

 
Fair comment, except why do the EU do it. It kills trade with Africa and S America and has no benefit for consumers. It’s protectionist and nothing else……

I think it protects European industry particularly agriculture, I think by doing this though it gives baseline, regulation, standards and support, the pay back is supply chain and certainty in the sector and so the mutality of the supply chain in terms of continuity, standard and support is met. I think we all know there are huge concerns around South American meat for example, it’s cheaper for a reason. @Bluerover worked at Goverment and administration and he’d know more then me, but just for illustrative purposes.

On the flip side the EU also promotes competition. For example I bought the same Battery Lawnmower of a German company online, 100 euro cheaper then the local B&Q here. I bought a Heineken Blade Beer machine 200 euro cheaper from Italy, equally stuff that uniquely Irish is cheap here. So from that point of view competition is rife amongst business’s all around Europe. That’s the market the U.K. can’t function in any more, a pity as I often bought things from U.K. business. I was after wall lights a couple of weeks back and I sourced ones I wanted in a UK electrical outlet, they were 40 euro for the lights, to bring them into the EU it was addition 60 odd euro estimated and the company said that may not be the final duty bill. Needless to say - no thanks.

Id propose the idea of Brexit is protectionist, wasn’t it all about, doing your own trade deals, reclaiming the borders, Britain doing what’s best for Britain, isn’t that protectionist. Leaving one block, to act as a smaller one.

What I often find weird is the U.K. is a collection of four countries, basically controlled by England looking after themselves from London mutually. The argument against the EU is it’s 28 countries looking after themselves from Brussels mutually. Essentially the same thing just the EU having broader scope and clout.

Brexit to my mind, was a bad political decision to hold a vote and went wrong, it wiped out a generation of U.K. politicians of a high caliber in resignations and left politicians of a low caliber to grab at power they never would normally have got near, be a good 10 years until the antivirus is run, but lads like Boris have a shelf life and the EU know it, it will be over soon, the coming recession might do it.
 
Last edited:
I think it protects European industry particularly agriculture, I think by doing this though it gives baseline, regulation, standards and support, the pay back is supply chain and certainty in the sector and so the mutality of the supply chain in terms of continuity, standard and support is met. I think we all know there are huge concerns around South American meat for example, it’s cheaper for a reason. @Bluerover worked at Goverment and administration and he’d know more then me, but just for illustrative purposes.

On the flip side the EU also promotes competition. For example I bought the same Battery Lawnmower of a German company online, 100 euro cheaper then the local B&Q here. I bought a Heineken Blade Beer machine 200 euro cheaper from Italy, equally stuff that uniquely Irish is cheap here. So from that point of view competition is rife amongst business’s all around Europe. That’s the market the U.K. can’t function in any more, a pity as I often bought things from U.K. business. I was after wall lights a couple of weeks back and I sourced ones I wanted in a UK electrical outlet, they were 40 euro for the lights, to bring them into the EU it was addition 60 odd euro estimated and the company said that may not be the final duty bill. Needless to say - no thanks.

Id propose the idea of Brexit is protectionist, wasn’t it all about, doing your own trade deals, reclaiming the borders, Britain doing what’s best for Britain, isn’t that protectionist. Leaving one block, to act as a smaller one.

What I often find weird is the U.K. is a collection of four countries, basically controlled by England looking after themselves from London mutually. The argument against the EU is it’s 28 countries looking after themselves from Brussels mutually. Essentially the same thing just the EU having broader scope and clout.

Brexit to my mind, was a bad political decision to hold a vote gone wrong, it wiped out a generation of U.K. politicians if a high caliber in resignations and left politicians of a low caliber to grab at power they never would normally, be a good 10 years until the antivirus is run, but lads like Boris have a shelf life and the EU know it, it will be over soon, the coming recession might do it.
Great post mate.

I am very aware that the UK electorate is entitled to make up its own mind, but objectively we are looking on from ROI and scratching our heads as to why the UK did what it did.

The EU is a PITA for MSs in many ways but the benefits of membership far outweigh the negatives. We punch above our weight because we usually try to find agreement where there is difficulty. Thus Ireland is seen as a positive influence overall in spite of our small population. That does not give us a free pass - nor should it btw - in terms of conformity with EU standards.

Yes the Commission is unelected and all powerful, but the upside is unfettered access to 500 million people

I had plenty of difficult meetings with Commission officialdom which, if they went wrong, could have cost Ireland hundreds of millions. It is not easy, one has to retain composure and determination, but the UK walking away from nearly fifty years of commitment was short sighted.

I know that plenty of my UK colleagues were really devastated with the Brexit vote as they understood the implications for GB. However, I don't think the GB voters gave a toss about the complications that would be caused in NI.

Sadly Brexit is being used by dinosaur 22% Donaldson to beat his Lambeg drum and disenfranchise 78% from having a NI Assembly and Executive
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top