Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
While Leave was not defined on the ballot paper, it most certainly was within the Government document sent to every household.

I don’t have any problem with a referendum that was between Mays deal and No Deal. We voted to leave, so I have no problem with a vote on which type of Leave we should have.

No deal only comes off the table once it becomes law. I certainly would put the death penalty to a referendum and the only reason it never will be is because once again the elite must be obeyed........
what's with all this 'elite' crap. The elite own all the right wing rags that have you in this mess.
 
While Leave was not defined on the ballot paper, it most certainly was within the Government document sent to every household.

I don’t have any problem with a referendum that was between Mays deal and No Deal. We voted to leave, so I have no problem with a vote on which type of Leave we should have.

No deal only comes off the table once it becomes law. I certainly would put the death penalty to a referendum and the only reason it never will be is because once again the elite must be obeyed........
  • Which bit defined 'Leave' in the leaflet?
  • May's deal and No Deal were not the only options available proposed during the referendum so why should they be the only options available to the electorate?
  • It's not a question of constitutional concern, so why would it be subject to plebiscite?
 
What question would you have on the referendum paper.
Option 1 is easy... "Revoke Article 50"
Option 2 is far more contentious and one that the HoC are never going to agree on. Option 2 needs to be leaving the EU with the deal that a majority of the HoC believe is the best way forward. The problem is, if we can get to that point where the HoC can get a majority then we'll just leave on those terms without it going to a referendum against the remain option.

For that reason, I can't see a referendum being a realistic way forward.
 
I find the group of people who say going against the initial referendum is so dangerous for democracy that it's better to just accept all of the problems that Brexit is going to bring to be the most loathsome of the bunch.
The problem with these vague posts is that you don't know who they are directed at. As it directly follows a post of mine in which I said I was against a second referendum, I'll assume I am one of the ones it is directed towards. If so, please tell me where I have said that going against the initial referendum is dangerous fro democracy.
 
The problem with these vague posts is that you don't know who they are directed at. As it directly follows a post of mine in which I said I was against a second referendum, I'll assume I am one of the ones it is directed towards. If so, please tell me where I have said that going against the initial referendum is dangerous fro democracy.
Why would you assume that? It seemed a comment on MPs to my eye.
 
what's with all this 'elite' crap. The elite own all the right wing rags that have you in this mess.

And the level of venom from the elite and its press is unprecedented. Our press is not the press of a sane democratic nation. Some of the of stuff you would expect to see in an extreme right wing dictatorship and is very concerning, since the "enemies of the people" was plastered all over the front pages there has not been much let up either. Much of the press is affront to democrocy.

 
Message from Dover:
hdcd0wgrl9q21.jpg
 
Option 1 is easy... "Revoke Article 50"
Option 2 is far more contentious and one that the HoC are never going to agree on. Option 2 needs to be leaving the EU with the deal that a majority of the HoC believe is the best way forward. The problem is, if we can get to that point where the HoC can get a majority then we'll just leave on those terms without it going to a referendum against the remain option.

For that reason, I can't see a referendum being a realistic way forward.
That's why I asked the question. I can't think of a question choice that would engage all of the leave vote except for a straightforward remain/leave. And we all know that isn't acceptable. Any referendum has to engage the whole of the electorate or it isn't democratic.
 
What question would you have on the referendum paper.

It is difficult. If no deal is expunged from the record then it will be whatever gets approved by the house and revoke or postpone until there is something that allows exiting without the problems we are facing with Ireland.

What we really need is about 35 million of those Men In Black memory erasers to be sent to every home to reset everyone back to before the referendum though.
 
  • Which bit defined 'Leave' in the leaflet?
  • May's deal and No Deal were not the only options available proposed during the referendum so why should they be the only options available to the electorate?
  • It's not a question of constitutional concern, so why would it be subject to plebiscite?

*The whole document defined Leave by spelling out all of the things we were going to lose. Yet even though studies have shown that the document had the desired effect of lowering the Leave vote, we still voted Leave.
*Because you wouldn’t want to confuse the ignorant voters
*Why not, we seem to be in a continual state of voting at the moment so let’s do the whole thing....
 
And the level of venom from the elite and its press is unprecedented. Our press is not the press of a sane democratic nation. Some of the of stuff you would expect to see in an extreme right wing dictatorship and is very concerning, since the "enemies of the people" was plastered all over the front pages there has not been much let up either. Much of the press is affront to democrocy.

Written by James Slack who is now Downing Street Press Secretary :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top