It took Arteta seven years I think to lift the trophy, should we be giving David a new six year contract?
The bit that sometimes gets lost when discussing Klopp, Arteta, Pep in his first season etc. is that the they retained the confidence of the fanbase because they had forward progression.
You could see the football style changing, then there was an improvement in league position, then continuous improvement, then challenging for trophies but falling short, then finally winning.
We don’t maintain the forward progression. No manager can get past a 12 month period of new manager bounce before the relegation form comes back in. Has happened to every manager since Martinez, some much quicker, other longer.
Just smacks either of poor squads that play up for a manager for a while but aren’t good enough to then move forward and just then phone it in once the novelty wears off. Or of poor managers that have an edge for a period with their plan A that gets results but once the league has cottoned on they can’t reinvent and results dip.