Clear Out

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think if they're serious about a top 6 spot, then the only players that would be good enough to start for a top 6 team would be Davies, Vlasic, Besic, Gueye, Pickford, Klaasen, Keane. Everyone else would only be good enough with a spot on the bench or as a backup.

Actually I think the team played better WITH Klaasen in the first few weeks than the last few without.

lol
 
Out in Jan at the absolute minimum: Williams, Martina, Besic, McCarthy, Schneiderlin, Mirallas, Lennon, loan Klaassen and DCL

Not sure why DCL is being loaned out, unless we're buying 2 strikers?
Also, Lennon gets binned but Klaasen gets a cushy loan somewhere?
 
Disagree with Klaassen and Sandro. Sandro needs to play on the left of a front 3 and left there, will add plenty. Klaassen hasn’t played centrally once.
Would be happy to see Davies go out on loan, as currently he is not good enough.


But as far as shipping out goes. Shame for Mccarthy and sad for Jags and Baines.
And just pure dross of Martina, Williams, Schneiderlin.
And I don’t think Mirallas has a future here either.
 
upload_2017-11-24_14-5-40.webp
 
How the hell can anyone watching Keane think he's a player, never mind a 30 million player?
He's not an athlete, he's not mobile, he's slow, his distribution is poor, he has an ungainly gait, he can't defend.... need I go on? This guy is actually in the England squad, wow. The usual case of a transfer fee dictating who gets into southgate's (and every England manager before him) squad.
Oh, I forgot, he started his career at Man U, so he must be good..............

Rooney was a huge mistake. He's done, and has been for a long time. I could see it, anyone with even a slight knowledge of football could see it. My Man U supporting in laws were telling me five years ago he was done. He's here to cash in his retirement funds. He needs to be told he's just not up to playing at this level anymore. He's not even championship quality these days.

Tom Davies is over-rated. Sorry folks. He lacks intelligence, pace and know-how. Yes, he's young and can learn, but he only gives endeavour and bite, that's about all. No real creativity.

Williams is a disaster - a disaster who can generally pass a ball (unlike jags and Keane) but who defends like a pub player.

sigurdsson......where to start?........ It's not his fault we paid 50 mill for him. But come on, he was never and never will be the creative player we need. Fooled by the 'assists' chart, no-one bothered to check that most of those assists were from corners and free-kicks. He's a cardboard cutout on the pitch, slow, immobile, uncomfortable on the ball and hasn't got a creative bone in his body.

Baines prefers the easy/safe option: to pass it square or back. He's hiding when he should be one of our leaders. We're missing Coleman badly. Couldn't see what anyone saw in schneiderlein either. Poor poor player.

The team is rotten to the core. A lot of this dead wood needs written off and shifted out of the club. If Walsh is responsible for this waste of money then he needs booted out of Goodison. I've never felt as disillusioned as an Everton supporter since the walker/smith/royle days. Slow tempo, slow players, no guile, no pace. We're total dung.

Need a new manager now and some players with a bit of guile and balls about them.

Don't know who the new manager should be. Not keen on dyche or allerdyce, but in our position can we afford to be choosey?

My choice would be silva or, dare I say it, Rodgers. I don't give a toss who he managed before. If he can save us, I'll take him.
 
Oh and we can sod off Stek. Absolutely a complete waste of space. Should never have brought him in for more than a 1 year deal. Besic as well, is just not good enough. Garbutt needs to go on loan and if he fails sold to Shrewbsury Town.

Of the current first team mix we should keep:
GK: Pickford, Robles
BACKS: Kenny, Coleman, Keane, Holgate
MIDS: Klaassen, Gana, Beni, Sigurdsson, Rooney, Davies
FWDS: DCL, Niasse, Sandro, Bolasie, Lookman, Lennon, Vlasic


Klaassen, needs to play centrally. Until he has a run, I will not judge – despite all the ridiculous comments about him. Sigurdsson, barely played centrally as well, I’ve thought it was bad signing and a complete waste but needs to play centrally.

I’m sure I have missed someone. But at this stage, that is it.
 
Out in Jan at the absolute minimum: Williams, Martina, Besic, McCarthy, Schneiderlin, Mirallas, Lennon, loan Klaassen and DCL
Considering none of those moves were hurt us one iota, why the heck not?

It is indeed more important to get in the CB, LB, and CF we need to be successful post January.

But I'm not so sure some of these younger guys have gotten poisoned by some of the poor characters in the squad. Might have to be quite a few loans, honestly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top