Supra??? The old AE86??? Celica GT-4??? IS300? LFA??? GT86??
There are plenty of awesome Toyota's out there. Their run-of-the-mill cars are the ones that are soulless.
The GT-86 is a Scion FR-S in the states. Its probably an good car, but has kind of bland styling. The Subaru GT-86 (BR-Z) is better equipped here in the states and will have a better resale value. The Celica is a Scion tC and its garbage.
I loved the old Supras and MR2s, but those days are long gone. Here in the states you get a choice of Avalon, Rav4, Land Cruiser, Yaris, Corolla, Tacoma, Camry, 4 Runner, and Prius.
Sadly the only cars that have any personality are the Land Cruiser which is impractical, and the Prius (which may not have the personality you want, but at least it has one).
Honda is guilty of the same thing. Of the Japanese manufactures only Mazda actually tries to put some personality in a car today. Subaru (though the Forester went from cool hybrid SUV to fat SUV for fat american behinds and the Impreza didn't really update their look) and Nissan sometimes do.