Big Dunc or Tim Cahill?

[Sharpys top lip]

Cahill. Fergie was a fraud.wouldn't say it to his face though...

OOOOOHH.







Pulls a chair**










{Ping}







nom,nom,nom,nom,noms

 

[spikeman]

Do tell me about Dixie.

He was fantastic, or the bees knees as we used to call it back in the day.

 

[Deleted member 28206]

I wrote to Fergie in jail, went to his first reserve game after being released. I'm a fan - but he was no Everton legend, certainly not in the classic way.Not on Cahills league - you'll get the instant kopite haters who tagged on to his one or two big game appearances( derby or utd) and would go missing for the rest!

 

[little curly alan ball]

Do tell me about Dixie.

Dixie had 20 odd years to wait .

Alexander Young - the first one . The murderer , is whom you require , lid .

 

[little curly alan ball]

I wrote to Fergie in jail, went to his first reserve game after being released. I'm a fan - but he was no Everton legend, certainly not in the classic way.Not on Cahills league - you'll get the instant kopite haters who tagged on to his one or two big game appearances( derby or utd) and would go missing for the rest!

I DID , lid !!!

Have you still got your reply cause I havent . I moved house twice in quick succession '02/03 time and lost all kinds of stuff - Me Arl Girl . THAT was among it . Me Wembley Ticket Stubs - all of them . Cricket stuff from 20 years earlier . Stone Roses autographed tickets . All kinds of [Poor language removed] , but Big Man's letter an' all . Ive met him loads since like . The kids had loads of bits , but Im still gutted .

 

[chicoazul]

He used to drink in Retro on Mathew Street, I had a boss conversation with him one night and then he let onto me a few more times in there.

It still ranx as one of my best achievements really.

 

[Bundy]

You're gay mate.

 

[chicoazul]

You're gay mate.

Yes mate, yes I am.

 

[TX Bill]

Both.

Legends.

(Voted for Cahill though.)

 

[Allezfan]

ON the pitch ; Timmy - we're far better now . Big man never played in Europe .

True. OTOH, Timmy hasn't won a trophie.

 

[little curly alan ball]

True. OTOH, Timmy hasn't won a trophie.

Kid , to say Big Man , " Won " the Trophy is STRETCHING IT , but I take your point .

 

[Lao]

ON the pitch ; Timmy - we're far better now . Big man never played in Europe .

OFF it ; Fergie . No question . Single-handedly kept the Toffee Shop in business . For years .

He did. Collina, Villareal??

 

[ToffeeBlueNose]

I think Dunc was a leader and someone who the fans loved for his fight and determination in dark times for us. He lifted the club and fans everytime because of his pure passion and he integrated himself as an Icon from his very first game.

I don't believe Cahill is a better player and think if it wasn't for his injuries Duncan would of been immense. If we put Duncan in this team would he do better, I imagine so but we'l never know, equally Cahill on the end of Hinchcliffes crosses would of been awesome too. I think both will be remebered as fan favourites.

 

[little curly alan ball]

He did. Collina, Villareal??

Oh , fuk , yeah .

Forgot '05 .

I was thinking Amo - 95 , Kanchelskis , 96 .

Cameos at best , mind

 

[little curly alan ball]

I think Dunc was a leader and someone who the fans loved for his fight and determination in dark times for us. He lifted the club and fans everytime because of his pure passion and he integrated himself as an Icon from his very first game.

I don't believe Cahill is a better player and think if it wasn't for his injuries Duncan would of been immense. If we put Duncan in this team would he do better, I imagine so but we'l never know, equally Cahill on the end of Hinchcliffes crosses would of been awesome too. I think both will be remebered as fan favourites.

Decent shout , as it goes .