barkley or rodwell

[timbo33]

Who is the better player now and out of the 2 who has greater potential, is food for thought

 

[Aidey9]

Who is the better player now and out of the 2 who has greater potential, is food for thought

Not really, Barkley wins hands down on both counts!.

 

[RFUS]

Jeffers.

 

[Neiler]

Two very different players. Couldnt possibly compare the two.

*Barkley though.

 

[Tubey]

Barkley is the better prospect and quite frankly already the better player purple monkey dishwasher.

 

[Lao]

Ross Jack, remember him - he was a mixture of both.

 

[timbo33]

Not really, Barkley wins hands down on both counts!.

apparently young mcalney looks good have you seen much of him?

 

[GWS]

Moyes attended a charity night in Preston a short while ago. He was asked that very question, and with remarable candour said, Barkley will not be as good as Rooney but will be better than Rodwell.

I always think Jack looks like he's trying to find his true position, which I still believe, long term, will be at centre back. Ross, however, looks completely at home throughout midfield. He is an exciting prospect.

But I wouldn't give up on Jack, even though his progress appears to have slowed.

 

[Aidey9]

apparently young mcalney looks good have you seen much of him?

He's a willing runner and as good movement but havent seen enough of him really. Does seem to get his fair share of goals for the reserves though.

 

[RFUS]

Moyes attended a charity night in Preston a short while ago. He was asked that very question, and with remarable candour said, Barkley will not be as good as Rooney but will be better than Rodwell.

I always think Jack looks like he's trying to find his true position, which I still believe, long term, will be at centre back. Ross, however, looks completely at home throughout midfield. He is an exciting prospect.

But I wouldn't give up on Jack, even though his progress appears to have slowed.

I hope Moyes didn't say that.

He's basically shat on both his players there, by saying to Ross that he will never be as good as Rooney and by saying to Rodwell that his 17 year old teammate is better than him.

 

[fozzy]

Who is the better player now and out of the 2 who has greater potential, is food for thought

hmmmmmmmmmm! cheese on toast!!

 

[tommye]

both scousers. both blues. love them both people....love them both. oh and Ross, Jack and that wilshire lid are gonna win the next world cup, and the one after that, on their own....just them 3!! You heard it here first folks. :yahoo:

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Vinny Samways.

 

[Jenko]

Rodwell. People say he needs to dictate the game and come out of his shell but he's a CB, what CB does that? He is as comfortable on the ball as, let's say Ferdinand, but he needs game-time and won't get that at CB which is why he's been moved to CM. He'll replace Distin in a few years and be immense.

Barkley will be part of our XI and as important as Fellaini is now. Hopefully partnering him.

 

[chicoazul]

Thanks for the food for thought there lad, did it have pineapple on it?