2017/18 Ashley Williams

[Papa Shango]

Another stupid decision.

Pennington should never have been loaned out when our CB cover is not so much sparse as non existent.

I dont think he is good enough personally but I do think its odd that he was perfectly fine to drop him into a derby match at Anfield and then decide its ok to go out on loan when we lack cover.

 

[AndyC]

It doesn't matter if he is rubbish or not. We don't have anybody else fit to play the role

Is a staggeringly sobering statement of fact... until Jags is fit or Williams gets injured, he's a fixture in the line-up.

 

[Darth Toffeeman]

Absolutely not.

I get that there's no one else to play right now with Jagielka and Keane injured, but we all know that when they're fit this idiot Williams will still be getting a game.

Agree that we should have given a centre back more priority.

That's what really angers me.

You could see we where crying out for 2 possibly even 3 Centre Halves. We bought Keane. Even buying Mee would have made sense to play alongside him.

We sold Lukaku thus we needed to revamp the entire defence and attack at once.

That was absolutely criminal by Everton.
Faith was put in Koeman and he appears to have failed and looks disinterested.
We are potentially back to the crisis of Smith days.

After years of steady construction under Moyes, when we finally do have money to spend we splurge it all on one paced dross. Martinez bought some duds and Koeman has applified the issue.

 

[Papa Shango]

Is a staggeringly sobering statement of fact... until Jags is fit or Williams gets injured, he's a fixture in the line-up.

Doesnt get much better further up the pitch either. We are pinning our hopes on a young kid and a bloke who was a competition winner and the worst signing in the history of anything ever 2 weeks ago.

All whilst spending stupid amounts of money.

Its an utter shambles.

 

[DanEFC92]

 

[marsh]

He is absolutely awful. And i didn't like him last season and i got moaned at for it

 

[sportset]

Has to join the list of worst players to wear an Everton shirt! Has been dire from the moment he joined us! Left any decent form with Wales before he joined us!

 

[KaiserEFC]

Without doubt one of the worst defenders I’ve seen for us

 

[TrixyStevens]

I can't stand him or his [Poor language removed] defending

 

[Mikey_Fitzgerald]

Actually made some good tackles last night

A Jekyll and Hyde player for sure

 

[welshtoffee]

Totally awful, mistakes are getting more often and the speed of a knackered traction engine

 

[Sy-]

Defended him last season, but now he's hit the level of poor that people were (incorrectly IMO) claiming he was last season.

Problem is, now he's directly costing us goals and showing some bizarre decision making, really not the time when you have a youngster next to you.

 

[ad4amt]

fire him in the sea like osama

 

[ToffeeTim]

An individual error every single game. Horrific signing. Gutless fraud here for a pay day before he retires.

 

[Stuartisitc1878]

he's up there with Alcaraz as one of the worst defenders to pull on the blue shirt. Absolutely awful!