Aiden McGeady

[EFCPaul]

He was MOTM against Lille in the EL. And I thought he did well round that period.

The thing is that these type of players are completely mood governed. A place and team and manager is either spot on for them or they suffer massive confidence issues. Of course, that's no good for a PL team looking for a bit more in the way of a robust mentality.

It's fair to say his time at Everton has been easily the worst in his career.

All told, he's from a different age really. I liked the idea of him being here because I love those type of players who can flick a switch and do the tricks. But it just hasn't worked out. Sadly for him and us.

Anyone saying he has no talent though has rocks in their head. Big ones.

MOTM?! Was that the game where he was awful and blew a golden chance for us to win the match? He, Lukaku and Eto'o were three on one with the goalkeeper and all he had to do was pass the ball into the box and instead he put it near the corner flag? I was there for that match, McGeady was absolutely dire.

 

[EFCPaul]

Deulofeu's immense performances since returning have all but ended McGeady's Everton career. Get shot in January and use the wages to bring in a loan.

 

[royvernon39]

It was good old Aiden who came on against WHU last season and who with Ossie really changed matters.

I think Aiden's goose was partly cooked when RM bought Lennon but there might still be a chance for him. If Miralles
leaves at Xmas, Aiden might get a chance on the left. He was the best player on the park for Ireland against England in the first half playing in that position this summer.

Lots of talent and he can do special things but for whatever reason he just has not establsihed himself.

 

[Bilko]

championship player I think,

 

[mawders]

It was good old Aiden who came on against WHU last season and who with Ossie really changed matters.

I think Aiden's goose was partly cooked when RM bought Lennon but there might still be a chance for him. If Miralles
leaves at Xmas, Aiden might get a chance on the left. He was the best player on the park for Ireland against England in the first half playing in that position this summer.

Lots of talent and he can do special things but for whatever reason he just has not establsihed himself.

He's just not very good

 

[Librarian]

Written in the stars that he'll win us some important game in miraculous circumstances making it all worthwhile

 

[tommye]

he was crap when we signed him and remains so.

 

[kithnou]

he was crap when we signed him and remains so.

Close the thread. Let these be his final words...

 

[Jags..class]

Well if kone can turn it round,maybe this guy can but Martinez had more faith in kone as he had more chances

 

[tommye]

He's had a load of chances and fluffs pretty much every one. Waste of a shirt, waste of a wage.

Feck him off back to Celtic asap.

 

[chrismpw]

I came on to this thread looking for a firm opinion on Aiden. I'm disappointed to find you all sitting on the fence.

 

[deipnosophist]

Aidan's injury woes and lack of form are a serious blow to the ASS. I can't see how it will recover.

One should never underestimate the ability of @kithnou 's ASS to absorb problematic circumstance. And whilst , on often occasion, it leaves itself wide open to abuse, ASS ,with all its clamouring members, will ultimately prevail.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Remember that miss against Wolfsburg though...

 

[blueser]

Having watched alot of him over the years i was dumbfounded when we signed him he is terrible i shudder to think the wages he is on and thats why his Sunderland move did not go through he is trunks and makes me question Martinez's judgement as Stevie Wonder could see that this lad is not up to the mark.

I will drive him to whereever is foolish enough to pay him to play football.

 

[Bob Elstone]

Needs to go to Sunderland or Villa or someone equally pants.