Was Dunc right for hooking Kean?

[ToffeeLee1878]

We were actually more likely to grab the winner when Prince Oumar entered the field ,Kean gave away two free kicks right when we needed to be up the other end of the pitch

 

[Harryflashman]

It’s tough to answer for any us because we don’t know what’s actually gone on ,but I do think we can assume that it Probably wasn’t merely tactical as suggested .

We know The previous manager hardly selected kean and we know he was late for team meetings , for me I think our current incumbent whose unbeaten against Chelsea & united made a decision and to be honest personally ok with it .

 

[Death]

Silva would have let it go on and stand there it a quivering lip.

 

[diggerdestroyer]

I don’t understand why he did it to be honest, Richarlison was utterly ruined at the end and should have been the one taken off. If he did it to waste time, waste it with Richarlisons substitution, not Keans. if he did it because he wasn’t happy with Kean, then given there was a only a few minutes left, leave him on and then drop him from the bench as punishment?

He didnt do it to waste time. He did it to make a point.

 

[Uncle Vitor]

so our of his depth we have four points v Chelsea and Man Utd.

And Crystal Palace won at Old Trafford. So what? Do you want Hodgson as a manager then?

 

[Papa Shango]

Hes the (caretaker) manager. He can do what he wants as long as he thinks its whats best for the team.

 

[PDAWG]

It's good to know what players we can count on of we find ourselves in a dog fight

Kean 100% isn't one of them

 

[ForeverBlue92]

Stupid decision and the sort of one that could turn the dressing room against him depending on if they are good mates with Kean.

It seems Dunc wants his CF running the channels like mad men all game.

Some are like that (DCL, Shane Long) whereas others (like Aguero, Jimenez) for example are more about being in and around the box looking to make things happen.

Shows his lack of experience.

I also worry if this is why the club have been so poor in addressing the CF position- do we focus on more wanting someone to run around like a mad man rather than signing your fox in the box type goal getter.

 

[LinekersLegs]

No one knows what sort of man management he’s had behind the scenes, he may of already had both the arm around the shoulder or a bollocking on the quiet in the hopes of getting a reaction, maybe this was the final attempt at giving him a kick up the hoop

The way that DCL, Davies and Holgate are playing (and the first two and the ball boys running to celebrate with Dunc last week) it doesn’t strike me that being cruel and heartless to youngsters is Fergusons typical man managerial style.

 

[Blueclouds]

Stupid decision and the sort of one that could turn the dressing room against him depending on if they are good mates with Kean.

It seems Dunc wants his CF running the channels like mad men all game.

Some are like that (DCL, Shane Long) whereas others (like Aguero, Jimenez) for example are more about being in and around the box looking to make things happen.

Shows his lack of experience.

I also worry if this is why the club have been so poor in addressing the CF position- do we focus on more wanting someone to run around like a mad man rather than signing your fox in the box type goal getter.

Really and we are in a position to play yo kean strengths.
God this is the worse post on here in ages

 

[Jim Hopper]

Silva would have let it go on and stand there it a quivering lip.

Doubt it mate, Silva wouldn’t have put him on until we were at least 3 goals down.

 

[bigboy]

It’s not just him taking him off for supposedly not following instructions. That’s understandable. He didn’t say a word to him and looked past him as if he wasn’t even there when coming off the pitch. Really left a bad taste in my mouth. I don’t think you should be treating anyone like that.

I feel like it wasn’t tactical and Dunc really doesn’t like Kean and he’s seen some opportunity to pull his kecks down.

 

[windymiller]

People on here defending Kean by pointing out he is still not fit. He's been here 5 months, hasn't had a single specific injury and is a professional athlete. If he's not fit then that is a terrible indictment of the young man.

 

[Gwladysstreetlad]

Awww, did the nasty old Everton manager sub off the poor little multi-millionaire for not doing what he was asked? How on earth will the delicate little rose petal cope with such a traumatic experience?!

 

[Ruairi77]

I get that he was making a point but he doesn’t have the job full time. Save antics like that till you know it’s your squad to shape.