James McCarthy

[blulouie]

He wasnt though was he let's be honest

More than done a job in a period we were comfortably best of the rest

You rate him...thats your opinion.

I cringed every time I saw him running onto the pitch at every game.
Ive seen some donkeys over the years but never a fraud bigger than that orrible finger pointing manc.
And his condiscending remarks about lil ole ev knowing its place made me vomit.
The very very worst of all of Moyes signings and.... he made plenty of them.

 

[Agent Blue]

Just leaving this here... the single greatest DFM performance i can remember .. one of the best individual games by anyone in an Everton shirt in the last 10 years ...

Edit: you know.. watch it just to bring a smile to this gloomy Saturday and to see the look on Toures face being dominated like no time in his career.

Yes its a crying shame he hasn't been given a run in the side, that was a superb performance against arguably the best side in the Prem. He has to stay fit though.

 

[evertonarntwe]

You rate him...thats your opinion.

I cringed every time I saw him running onto the pitch at every game.
Ive seen some donkeys over the years but never a fraud bigger than that orrible finger pointing manc.
And his condiscending remarks about lil ole ev knowing its place made me vomit.
The very very worst of all of Moyes signings and.... he made plenty of them.

Hardly rating him, he just wasnt a rubbish buy

He was a solid player In what was a good period for us

 

[BornBlue76]

Yes its a crying shame he hasn't been given a run in the side, that was a superb performance against arguably the best side in the Prem. He has to stay fit though.

I have realised that this is why I was anti JMac... i was so frustrated by him being sidelined by RM every time JMac was fit no matter how much more Besic could offer or that his ceiling is/was immeasurably higher. McCarthy is a one dimensional player whereas Besic had so much ammunition available... the level of favouritism was criminal.

I’ve accepted we didn’t use Besic properly which along with injuries from him trying too hard to impress resulted in him not fulfilling his potential... I still wonder what could have been ...

 

[Jayhow15]

Is Besic injured at moment? Has he travelled with 1st team. Pretty much forgot he existed to be honest.

 

[davek]

Yobo is our best premier league defender for me.

If you compare what he succeeded he looked impressive. His speed alone was welcome after the Weir fiasco.

 

[Charlie Sweet]

I have realised that this is why I was anti JMac... i was so frustrated by him being sidelined by RM every time JMac was fit no matter how much more Besic could offer or that his ceiling is/was immeasurably higher. McCarthy is a one dimensional player whereas Besic had so much ammunition available... the level of favouritism was criminal.

I’ve accepted we didn’t use Besic properly which along with injuries from him trying too hard to impress resulted in him not fulfilling his potential... I still wonder what could have been ...

In my opinion Besic isn't fit to place McCarthy's boots. Other than one single 45 min spell against City and a bit of pitch thumping after he'd injured himself in front of the Park End he's never done a thing for us.

By comparison McCarthy has been solid Premier League standard. Besic is a Championship yard dog at best.

 

[KaiserEFC]

Had 1 good season.

 

[Bigduke1234]

Yobo is our best premier league defender for me.

Good question.

Always liked yobo but he had a howler in him.

I’ll raise you lescott, was a period of time when I just knee wouldn’t concede from a set piece. Hopefully Mina brings that back

 

[KaiserEFC]

Yobo is our best premier league defender for me.

Was a big fan but Distin was a beast for a long time

 

[Exeter_Gently]

If you compare what he succeeded he looked impressive. His speed alone was welcome after the Weir fiasco.

Weir fiasco?

 

[davek]

Weir fiasco?

His chronic lack of pace.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

His chronic lack of pace.

Jesus you can't knock David Weir?! 200 grand. Despite his lack of pace we certainly got more than our moneys worth from him.

 

[Billysgingham.]

His chronic lack of pace.

Weir was good for us no doubt.

 

[orly]

You rate him...thats your opinion.

I cringed every time I saw him running onto the pitch at every game.
Ive seen some donkeys over the years but never a fraud bigger than that orrible finger pointing manc.
And his condiscending remarks about lil ole ev knowing its place made me vomit.
The very very worst of all of Moyes signings and.... he made plenty of them.

Absolutely right, plus his Dad was a complete danger