James McCarthy

[Blueclouds]

Always liked him and his aggression but his body not up to it as he plays like a terrier. Sell him this summer

 

[RichardP]

Lots of polar opposite opinions about McCarthy. For that reason alone, I would keep him. If he really is only worth a few million £ then we have everything to gain and relatively little to lose by giving him a chance.

 

[mrb85]

Before his leg break McCarthy was playing very well, basically playing further than usual up the field in order to do Lukaku's pressing for him!

 

[Goat]

Lots of polar opposite opinions about McCarthy. For that reason alone, I would keep him. If he really is only worth a few million £ then we have everything to gain and relatively little to lose by giving him a chance.

Im a big fan of his talent myself, hes very limited, but hes very, very good at what he does, for me his talent has never been the issue.

Yes hes been very unlucky with the leg break, but sadly hes not somebody we can rely on.

 

[orly]

Was limited at Wigan and has had one good half season here. His legend grows on the sideline.

Sell, or release into the wild.

 

[Zatara]

Lots of polar opposite opinions about McCarthy. For that reason alone, I would keep him. If he really is only worth a few million £ then we have everything to gain and relatively little to lose by giving him a chance.

Im a big fan of his talent myself, hes very limited, but hes very, very good at what he does, for me his talent has never been the issue.

Yes hes been very unlucky with the leg break, but sadly hes not somebody we can rely on.

Too injury prone...i liked him but playing for Ireland when he was coming off yet another injury did it for me.

I think hes getting a few mins simply to show teams hes fit and available.

 

[Izzy1878]

His nickname 'sick note' actually stems from his school days, where he was adept at forging parents' signatures in order to excuse unenthusiastic pupils from PE lessons.

 

[ijjysmith]

Ffs. Thought we’d sold him then.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

He stinks of Bournemouth.

 

[Buckers]

Always liked him and in his last comeback he looked good. Dont think he suits us now though at all. Time to sell. So long James.

 

[Death]

Not in the humour going back from when this was bumped. How much we get for him?

 

[Brett Angell Delight]

Ffs. Thought we’d sold him then.

There should be another index for people who randomly bump the threads of squad players we’re trying to flog.

 

[Howards tipple]

Ffs. Thought we’d sold him then.

Me too!!!

 

[dublinbluenose]

He desperately needs a move to restart his career, if only for Ireland's sake. We've nothing in midfield at the moment.

Feel.sorry for him, he played many times through injury and pain killing injections under Martinez to the detriment of his own body. Sadly paid the penalty for that.

He's too good for The SPL so would be pointless going there for sectarian abuse every 2nd week.

 

[BigBlueConk]

Looks like a Sunderland type player to me.