What makes you not convinced about him then? Is it just because some other keepers turned out not very good in the past? It's not his fault he has to face loads of shots because Sunderland are awful, he very rarely makes a mistake and Sunderland fans think he's been one of the only shining lights for them this season.
I don't think he commands his box very well to be honest. He's got a touch of the Shay Given's for me. Who incidentally was another keeper people used to crow about a number of saves he used to make. The Newcastle fans used to call him world class. Turns out he wasn't that good either.
Pickford maybe a good shot-stopper, but so are most of the other premier league goalkeepers. I want a bit more from a Everton keeper myself. But maybe that's just me.
If we do end up signing him I hope he proves me wrong though.