David Moyes' best signing

[Toffeeslam]

Joseph Yobo was decent too

 

[Norwegian Cow]

coleman. has been starter in our team for so many years, also was a steal.

 

[Number_25]

Nigel Martyn, easily.

 

[Khalekan]

Has to be Seamus.

Cahill a close second.

Though I voted for Jags on account it would be a shame if he ended up friendless in this Poll

 

[Albertini78]

Remember when yous sold Lescott and he signed Distin for yous for around £5m thinking WTF really was a solid player for yous though wasn't he ? Amazed he never got capped for France tbh

 

[Joey66]

Walter Smith signing I think.

spot on by one week before DM took charge

 

[Sharpys top lip]

Piennar by a mile....


Close thread!!!!

 

[Tree13]

100%! I will never get the distin love fest myself though... too one footed. Lescott and Jags partnership never replaced.

Lescott and Jags both very one-footed players also. A great partnership, certainly... but strange to highlight Distin as one-footed and be critical of it, yet ignore the same in two other players.

 

[Blue Cheese]

Pienaar was a superb footballer, very under rated.

 

[Prevenger17]

Though I voted for Jags on account it would be a shame if he ended up friendless in this Poll

Have switched my vote to Jags. I love Tim, but this is a shameful lack of recognition for a once-exceptional centre half. Years have depleted him, but memories are ludicrously short here

 

[ToffeeTim]

Matteo Ferrari

 

[Khalekan]

Have switched my vote to Jags. I love Tim, but this is a shameful lack of recognition for a once-exceptional centre half. Years have depleted him, but memories are ludicrously short here

Yay.....good man yerself, Prev

 

[Khalekan]

Remember when yous sold Lescott and he signed Distin for yous for around £5m thinking WTF really was a solid player for yous though wasn't he ? Amazed he never got capped for France tbh

For sure.

 

[evertonarntwe]

tim cahill

scored in countless derbies ( most goals after the war era init? ) how many important goals in general did he score?

still puts his lads in everton clobber now.

propa guy him

 

[chrismpw]

Soooo difficult.
In terms of quality it has to be Baines and Martyn.
In terms of team then Cahill.
In terms of being in the right place on the pitch at the right time, and being prepared to get hurt then Jags and Cahill.
In terms of find of the century then Coleman