David Moyes' best signing

Mikey_Fitzgerald · January 3, 2017

Fellaini

On his day with Moyes at the helm, he was imperious

Blue Cheese · January 3, 2017

I voted Martyn because he was a breath of fresh air and the best since Nev but all of them deserve credit they all played their part in some good years, just no pot to show for it.

Papa Shango · January 3, 2017

Joseph Yobo. I loved Joseph Yobo.

Probably Cahill to be honest but I just wanted to mention Yobo...

ianefc · January 3, 2017

Pienaar.

Wonderful footballer.

paulbefc · January 3, 2017

That lot for about £15m. Unbelievable from Moist.

orly · January 3, 2017

ianefc said:
Pienaar.

Wonderful footballer.

Changed the way this club was playing football at the time and grossly underrated.

His later career troubles and being ridiculously overlooked for the Sniveller on the left hand side of our team made is time here end on a low note, like his voice

zzebra · January 3, 2017

Cahill.

And to think we only got him because Palace wouldn't pay the agent fees.

GwladysPhil · January 3, 2017

Cahill is a good shout, but he became a passenger for the last couple of seasons he was with us.

I'm going for Baines - as he became one of the best left backs in the world when he was assisting for fun.

Tree13 · January 3, 2017

Pretty sure there's someone missing off that list...

Prevenger17 · January 3, 2017

Groucho said:
I imagine this will morph into a 'what is a legend' debate too.

"Groucho in b4 descent of thread into anarchy"

Prevenger17 · January 3, 2017

Cahill, for my money. Nobody compares in my mind

ianefc · January 3, 2017

paulbefc said:
That lot for about £15m. Unbelievable from Moist.

Correct.

He was fantastic for us in the market.

Joey66 · January 3, 2017

Groucho said:
Perhaps a foregone concision as Tim Cahill wins every poll he is included in, but as a distraction to today's return to work, just wondering out loud.

Poll does not show who you voted for.

I imagine this will morph into a 'what is a legend' debate too.

Lee Carsley not in there worth a shout?

Prevenger17 · January 3, 2017

paulbefc said:
That lot for about £15m. Unbelievable from Moist.

Aye, when you see it in that context, he was an effing miracle worker

BornBlue76 · January 3, 2017

Arteta was the best player in our side without a shadow of a doubt ... in my opinion... Cahill was a fan favourite for his attitude and fighting spirit... but best? Arteta was an artist!