Well I'm not really rating it, it doesn't get a score for instance, I'm just looking at whether it's worth playing now
That's really what I do with the Retro write ups
I play a Retro game and see whether it holds up or not
The Retro market is big at the moment and games like Super Soccer can be bought quite easily. There could be people who have never played this who are thinking about adding it to their SNES collection
It's not really a review in the traditional sense, because, as you say, gaming has changed a lot and the criteria I'd use for reviewing a modern release isn't really valid when used in reference to an older game
However, I do know people who have bought a Mega Drive/SNES/PS1/N64 who have found these features useful when considering whether to pick a game up or not, especially the higher priced ones. They are usually younger folk who have never had one of those consoles until now and they want to make sure they'll get games that they'll have fun playing
Plus, older people who remember these games like the trip down memory lane