Did you actually ever watch him play? He did a decent job for us and was part of the transition from us being relegation fodder to a more solid team. Worked hard, good in the air, helped his fullback out. Stat bros obviously won't understand the nuances have probably never participated in any team sport in their lives.
I seemed to watch him play for an eternity such was his laborious style. I'm not a stat bro, I understand they only have a limited value, but the stats back up what I saw with my eyes which is that he wasn't very good at anything. Nice fella, bad footballer. The fact that nobody can say anything better about him than he worked hard says a lot. Hard work should be a minimum requirement.
Anyway this is the transfer thread, not the was Kilbane rubbish or slightly better than rubbish thread. Sign someone better than Kilbane, Kinnear.