Would you take Martinez back?

Roberto back in the goodison hotseat?

  • Of course

    Votes: 61 20.0%
  • Nah

    Votes: 244 80.0%

  • Total voters
    305
Status
Not open for further replies.

You still seem unsure of the overarching point despite having asked twice.

Let me be concise and see if it helps.

Martinez was aiming to smash the glass ceiling created by Moyes dour defensive hoof ball so his target was BETTER than 6th or 7th and ultimately trophies to re-align the club with it's great historic traditions. The promising first season with the introduction of fabulous loanees and moderate buys (relative to the elite clubs) put us on the starting blocks but only a simpleton could not see we needed a SQUAD of such talent to press on and we didn't have the dough to do it.

The dregs of the market and players of Moyes glass ceiling era were never going to cut it and the inevitable collapse began.The crazy thing is we've since reverted to lowest common denominator football with Koeman and Allardyce and look at the screeching from the faithful!!!

This is quite a simple premise if you clear your mind of Moyes 6th or 7th without silverware being what this club is about, but if you can't you can't - try not to fret about it

“moyes dour defensive hoof ball” is an absolute embarrassment of a statement. We certainly didn’t play that type of football when we had a side containing Arteta, Peinaar, Lescott, Jags, Baines etc, you are talking out of your arse on that point.

I appreciate your well put together post, but it’s a complete fantasy as was any idea Martinez had of smashing this imaginary “glass ceiling” you have put together in your head. He was out of his depth once Moyes side broke up, the football was terrible and he went from bad to worse.

keep imagining him to have been better than that, but he wasn’t.
 
“moyes dour defensive hoof ball” is an absolute embarrassment of a statement. We certainly didn’t play that type of football when we had a side containing Arteta, Peinaar, Lescott, Jags, Baines etc, you are talking out of your arse on that point.

I appreciate your well put together post, but it’s a complete fantasy as was any idea Martinez had of smashing this imaginary “glass ceiling” you have put together in your head. He was out of his depth once Moyes side broke up, the football was terrible and he went from bad to worse.

keep imagining him to have been better than that, but he wasn’t.
I appreciate your conviction and respect your opinion I just disagree, mate.
 

How many points did we have in 87 when we won the Title?

If you can tell me that without googling it then I will concede that points in a season is important.

The points you get do not matter, only the place you finish.

The point is, in order to get more points, you have to win more games and lose fewer. Which we did. We also finished 4th with a minus goal difference. I guess that is some achievement to be fair.

When we won the league, I was 5, so I honestly couldn't tell you without looking, but I do know it will have a) been more points, and b) been more games in the season.

But i digress, the difference between a league title winning side and the difference between finishing 4th or 5th is ridiculous, and you know it.

So if we win the league on less points than Moyes got in his 4th place season, you’d rank that as a lesser achievement?

Go away.

Now, I didn't say that did I. Might wanna read it back.

Also, go away? Hahahahaha.

Am I not allowed to have an opinion (not the 1 you thought I had mind) that is contrary to one's you've been told to have?
 
Three seasons under Martinez = a 5th spot, 2 cup SFs, last 16 in Europe...on a minimal spend

Three seasons under Moshiri = a 7th spot, nowhere in the cups, nowhere in Europe....after handing hsi variety of hand picked plant pots a mountain of cash.

"The Mosh" really had some people off.

More inconvenient truths.
What utter drivel. Moshiri is not our manager and Martinez would possibly have got us relegated. The further he went from Moyes team the worse it got. Moshiri is a committed investor, no more. Brands and Silva will work but they have had neither time nor the rub of the green.
 
What utter drivel. Moshiri is not our manager and Martinez would possibly have got us relegated. The further he went from Moyes team the worse it got. Moshiri is a committed investor, no more. Brands and Silva will work but they have had neither time nor the rub of the green.
Genuine question, what makes you think it will work with brands and Silva mate ?
 

The point is, in order to get more points, you have to win more games and lose fewer. Which we did. We also finished 4th with a minus goal difference. I guess that is some achievement to be fair.

When we won the league, I was 5, so I honestly couldn't tell you without looking, but I do know it will have a) been more points, and b) been more games in the season.

But i digress, the difference between a league title winning side and the difference between finishing 4th or 5th is ridiculous, and you know it.



Now, I didn't say that did I. Might wanna read it back.

Also, go away? Hahahahaha.

Am I not allowed to have an opinion (not the 1 you thought I had mind) that is contrary to one's you've been told to have?
If the league is very competitive you might win it with lower points but actually a bigger achievement. Everything has to be put in to context.
 
The point is, in order to get more points, you have to win more games and lose fewer. Which we did. We also finished 4th with a minus goal difference. I guess that is some achievement to be fair.

When we won the league, I was 5, so I honestly couldn't tell you without looking, but I do know it will have a) been more points, and b) been more games in the season.

But i digress, the difference between a league title winning side and the difference between finishing 4th or 5th is ridiculous, and you know it.



Now, I didn't say that did I. Might wanna read it back.

Also, go away? Hahahahaha.

Am I not allowed to have an opinion (not the 1 you thought I had mind) that is contrary to one's you've been told to have?

Im just trying to prove that points arent important mate.

I mean Liverpool havent won the league in 30? years, but their points total last season would have been enough to win it most seasons.

Points dont matter.

72 points is great, we all were blown away by his first season, but then he failed for 2 whole seasons.
 
My post from the Moshiri thread. Just my two pence on this. Remember the only time he was able to spend at the top table he got Lukaku:

"We had the man in place in Martinez. I just think the mistake that Moshiri made was giving into the massive pressure of the fan base and media to let him go as a sign of the new era of ownership. Yes there were rocky times and awful derby performances in RM's three seasons in charge but the fact of the matter is that he was trying to implement a much more attractive and progressive offensive style of game on a shoe string budget with a group of players that were drilled by Moyes in the rigid structures and negative (yet reasonably effective) style of game. When FM came in, if Martinez was given the funds that the managers since him had to spend (plus that which was wasted on multiple manager payoffs) we'd be looking more like Leicester or dare I say it Spurs of the last few seasons than this one that has no style of play and is wallowing in mediocrity with no light at the end of the tunnel."

Quote Reply
Report
 
If the league is very competitive you might win it with lower points but actually a bigger achievement. Everything has to be put in to context.

Like I said, I made no comparison to the League winning sides. I said the difference between 4th with a minus goal difference and 5th with a record points total shows a difference in respective seasons. That's all. It doesn't take anything away from the achievement of finishing 4th, but nor should anything be taken away from achieving our highest points total since we previously won the league.
 
Genuine question, what makes you think it will work with brands and Silva mate ?
Because at times we are really good. We have suffered key injuries and bad calls with VAR. We also still have deadwood to get rid of so we can get genuine depth in the squad. Silva has shown excellence but needs a deeper squad to make it consistent. I really think we should get behind the slightly longer term plan.

Brands said he made this clear to Moshiri. Something like if you want success tomorrow I am the wrong man. If you want longer term sustainable success then yes. The whole thing includes the academy and bringing on young players. I think after one more summer window we can begin to see really where we are.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top