Why have America never produced a world class football player ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
They don't have the ancient tribal football loyalties with hordes of fans travelling all over the country on a weekend.
Also they abhor a draw. Someone has to win.
 
Too busy shooting each other
source.gif
 
They don't have the ancient tribal football loyalties with hordes of fans travelling all over the country on a weekend.
Also they abhor a draw. Someone has to win.
Football also doesn't have enough commercial breaks. 45 minutes without a sponsor segment would make most of them lightheaded.
 
There's a long list of reasons tbh, but my guess is within the next decade this won't be true anymore. Not that the US team will be any good still, but getting just one world class player is a bit of a thing that has to happen at some point. Almost every country does at some point.
 
Thank Title IX for that. Colleges/High schools have to treat female and male sports equally. To offset American football, schools had to add a lot of other sports for females (like footy) to even it out.
Actually it wasn't so much about adding ladies sports as it was about cutting men's. Many many mens fußball teams were cut as title IX came in.

The men's game in America has come a long long way but what that demonstrates is how large the gap was. Don't forget though, in 2002 they were a ball cleared off the line by a gerrman defenders arm from likely making the world cup semis...nothing to sneeze at.
 
Yes most Division 1 schools have soccer scholarships. That being said a few schools may cut their soccer programs due to the revenue lost from Coronavirus. University of Cincinnati already has. Also most college players arent going to make it far as pros if you think about the development timeline compared to other nations. By the time you are out of college youre 21/22, most quality academy players globally tend to make their first team appearances at 17-19.

Talent isnt the issue, its identifying it and developing it is where US Soccer comes up short. The pay to play model is disastrous to our development and a key reason we lag behind. Look at all the top performing nations. They have pro teams with their own academies and youth systems in nearly every city in the country.

Article on Pulisic's development from 2 years ago. Helps his father was a coach.

I know it is heresy to say this, but pay to play isn't the issue...there are always spots for kids that will help these teams win thereby ensuring the next wave of playing customers...it is truly an infrastructure issue where there just aren't enough coaches with knowledge to move kids along...my children have all experienced st least one lost year of development due to having coaches that may never have even watched a game on the TV let alone played...the number of kids that have had decent or better coaching every season throughout their childhood is probably quite small.
 
They don't have the ancient tribal football loyalties with hordes of fans travelling all over
I know it is heresy to say this, but pay to play isn't the issue...there are always spots for kids that will help these teams win thereby ensuring the next wave of playing customers...it is truly an infrastructure issue where there just aren't enough coaches with knowledge to move kids along...my children have all experienced st least one lost year of development due to having coaches that may never have even watched a game on the TV let alone played...the number of kids that have had decent or better coaching every season throughout their childhood is probably quite small.
I definitely agree that it's an infrastructure issue but I believe the pay to play model goes hand in hand with that. Like you said theres a lack of quality coaches and the few decent coaches there are tend to be employed by these more expensive travel/pay to play teams. Yes some exceptional players may get their fees waived. Tim Howard for example attended a single $25 dollar per session training session held by a former US U-17 coach when he was young. The coach then offered Tim free training as he was impressed with his skills (Tim has said his mom could only afford the one session at the time). This doesnt happen for every talented young player though.

The lack of academies/organized development is a major issue along with not enough scouting from US Soccer
 
Biggest reason is footy isn't seen in the same light as football, basketball or even baseball, despite "soccah's" worldwide footprint.
It may be because I'm in my mid twenties but baseball was never a big deal growing up here. Football and Basketball are by far the most popular. I'll have to look up the numbers but I would expect nowadays the numbers of American youth playing soccer will be close, if not higher than baseball.

Edit: Actually I'm wrong based of the link below. That being said football is massively popular here and has lower numbers than soccer and baseball for this (6-12 age group).

 
It may be because I'm in my mid twenties but baseball was never a big deal growing up here. Football and Basketball are by far the most popular. I'll have to look up the numbers but I would expect nowadays the numbers of American youth playing soccer will be close, if not higher than baseball
I'm talking up to this generation when the shift began and people realize there's a lot of money to be made in the sport, for those so athletically inclined. The best players have been mid-table european quality at best. Love Dempsey the player, but he wasn't good enough for Spurs.
 
Actually it wasn't so much about adding ladies sports as it was about cutting men's. Many many mens fußball teams were cut as title IX came in.

The men's game in America has come a long long way but what that demonstrates is how large the gap was. Don't forget though, in 2002 they were a ball cleared off the line by a gerrman defenders arm from likely making the world cup semis...nothing to sneeze at.
College soccer isn't a nearly competitive development system though.
 
I'm talking up to this generation when the shift began and people realize there's a lot of money to be made in the sport, for those so athletically inclined. The best players have been mid-table european quality at best. Love Dempsey the player, but he wasn't good enough for Spurs.
We've got a few players at perennial CL clubs right now. Pulisic, Adams, Reyna. Dest looks set to move to one too. It is getting better, but not because of the US, just getting guys into better academies abroad.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top