Who is the worst Everton player you have seen in the Premier League era?

[efcste97]

Imagine giving a middle finger to that post. Delicate flower aren't you?

Irony because you're taking the proverbial out of someone for saying Doucoure, then picking Iwobi, who isn't even CLOSE to being our worst player in the PL era (as demonstrated above). He's not even the worst player in the current squad.

Yeah because it's crazy that someone put Doucoure on a 'worst' list, I didn't call the fella out and i'm sorry if it came across that way.

For what we paid Iwobi is easily one of the worst signings in the clubs history

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

For what we paid Iwobi is easily one of the worst signings in the clubs history

Which isn’t the question asked by the thread.

 

[Papa Shango]

I thought it would be a long list. I don't think some of the names should be there mind you. Yes Paul Holmes was a shocker. Hottiger, Alcatraz, Kroldrup, Williamson, Linderoth, Thomas, all should be on there. I think David Burrows was a poor player. Players from the early 90's/Kendall/Walker absolutely dire. I'm starting to think we will also be adding Rondon.

WIlliamson should only be on the list of we are judging players by what we got out from them due to injury.

He played about 20 games for us, including a great showing in the Goodison derby that year before getting a career ending injury. He is in the Gbamin/Kone category.

Burrows is a great shout. Swapped him for Tony Cottee just after we signed Ferguson, they probably could have made a great pairing too. We didn't need him either as we had Hinchcliffe and Ablett. A complete non entity who always looked weird in blue.

 

[Tree13]

Earl Barrett
Iain Jenkins
Marc Hottiger
Jon O’Connor
Adam Eaton
John Spencer
Gareth Farrelly (1 sublime moment apart)
John O’Kane
Graham Allen
Mitch Ward
Tony Thomas
John Oster
Phil Jevons
Michael Branch
Peter Degn
Jamie Milligan
Stephen Hughes
Mark Hughes
Peter Clarke
Alex Nyarko
Kevin McLeod
Nick Chadwick
David Ginola
Li Weifeng
Mark Hughes
Iain Turner
Per Kroldrup
Simon Davies
Anderson Da Silva

There’s 30 with like 15 seasons to spare

How on Earth has this list made me smile?

Well done sir. Hard to disagree.

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

How on Earth has this list made me smile?

Well done sir. Hard to disagree.

It’s simultaneously depressing and heartening, isn’t it?

 

[Tree13]

It’s simultaneously depressing and heartening, isn’t it?

Weirdly so, yes. Gallows humour, perhaps.

 

[Alanbileysfeathercut]

Earl Barrett
Iain Jenkins
Marc Hottiger
Jon O’Connor
Adam Eaton
John Spencer
Gareth Farrelly (1 sublime moment apart)
John O’Kane
Graham Allen
Mitch Ward
Tony Thomas
John Oster
Phil Jevons
Michael Branch
Peter Degn
Jamie Milligan
Stephen Hughes
Mark Hughes
Peter Clarke
Alex Nyarko
Kevin McLeod
Nick Chadwick
David Ginola
Li Weifeng
Mark Hughes
Iain Turner
Per Kroldrup
Simon Davies
Anderson Da Silva

There’s 30 with like 15 seasons to spare

Imagine if you put your mind it......

 

[Papa Shango]

Imagine if you put your mind it......

Probably be quicker to name the good ones.

 

[efcste97]

Which isn’t the question asked by the thread.

I cannot make judgement on players I haven't seen therefore that rules out some on this list from pre 2004, as that is when I started going the game regularly and was old enough to actually know what was going.

Based on that, Iwobi is still right up there and on personal reasonings as to how I judge players he'll still get my vote. Rondon close second followed by Martina.