Which 'Phil' was the better Everton skipper?

[4737carlin]

Jagielka has been ace, his best playing days are long gone but in his day a top player and blue, finest moment Wembley

 

[Walken]

Pair of losers

 

[EFCPaul]

Phil Taylor would be a better captain than either of these two.

 

[Frang]

phil mcCrakin

 

[goodisonopheliac]

Phil Swagielka.

 

[B17BLG]

Might just be me but I find it a bit embarrassing that this goal is still celebrated so much. We scored in the last minute to draw against Liverpool but you’d think it was the winner in the FA Cup final the way people still go on about it.

Sorry fràndel. I haven't had much to celebrate in my 27 years of Everton supportership.

Make of that what you will.

 

[abelard]

Jags, obviously.

Are all of you too young to have seen him play, pre-Martinez?

The only thing more outlandish than the premise of the question is the fact that it took my vote to break the tie between the two.

Neville was like a slower, less-ambitious Tom Cleverley.

 

[DanEFC92]

Neville.

 

[MikeH72]

Both are rubbish captains in the grand scheme of things, however we did visibly miss Neville's presence and organisation on the pitch when he wasn't playing. You can't say the same about cuddly old Jags.

 

[Nymzee]

Both are/were crap captains.

 

[SerenityNigh]

Can't vote for anyone who had blonde highlights past 2003 or so.

 

[Dario Terracotta]

Like Jags as a player and person, but captain?not for me,I think Neville probably just shades it as a skipper, but only just!!

 

[Runcornblue52]

Jags...People now typically trying to rubbish him as he comes near to the end of his career, but he has been a lion for Everton !

 

[dave abrahams]

Might just be me but I find it a bit embarrassing that this goal is still celebrated so much. We scored in the last minute to draw against Liverpool but you’d think it was the winner in the FA Cup final the way people still go on about it.

I bet you didn't think like that on the day it went in. !!!!!!

 

[efcjames]

Jagielka, both average though