Was Dunc right for hooking Kean?

Was Dunc right to hook Kean?

  • Total voters
    705
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

LouReedwalkonthewildside said:
How does that work considering most of the world would have seen what happened?
Click to expand...

Because an out of favour, out of sorts player at war with the club has a significantly lower transfer value than if Everton maintain a stance that he’s an important player and, despite appearances, all is well.

Anyone with a brain watching that today knows that there are issues behind closed doors, but with Ferguson and Everton continuing to publicly deny that, insisting they are happy for Kean to stay and believe he can contribute to the team moving forward, the club will have a much better chance of negotiating a deal closer to his market value. In other words, his value doesn’t drop dramatically - irrespective of the guff Kean, his agent, his Dad or anyone else say in the media to engineer a move in January (which I fully expect to happen in the coming weeks).
 
tommye said:
tenor.gif
Click to expand...
I couldn't be arsed checking to see if it was spelt right
 

Keiran said:
Because an out of favour, out of sorts player at war with the club has a significantly lower transfer value than if Everton maintain a stance that he’s an important player and, despite appearances, all is well.

Anyone with a brain watching that today knows that there are issues behind closed doors, but Everton publicly deny that, state they are happy for Kean to stay and believe he can contribute to the team moving forward, the club will have a much better chance of negotiating a deal closer to his market value. In other words, his value doesn’t drop dramatically.
Click to expand...

So Ferguson saying what he did will convince people.
 
longers said:
Bit harsh that he of all players had to suffer this embarrassment given the likes of Schnieds etc have put in countless performances with zero effort over multiple years and never been humilated in such fashion.
Click to expand...
But as eloquently pointed out by @Bob Latchford Morgan was a changed man last week.

”Special mention for Morgan Schneiderlin who played like Dunc had his family held hostage at a remote country farmhouse.”
 
Dunc's job is to manage the team, and then the game once that team is out there doing its job. He made a call. We've bagged 4 points from 6 from two of the hardest fixtures out there.

A clear line was drawn about effort today, one of the major characteristics that's seeped away since Moyes. Today it was Kean, but I think there's half a dozen squad players that can look forward to the same. Well done Big Dunc.
 

So much fuss made about Keans sub, he should just turn up at training knuckle down and try to impress, he may only be 19 but he’s paid a lot of money to perform and in half a season we have seen very little of him. Even silva didn’t play him perhaps he isn’t that good or still not ready, sulking back to ltaly would just make him look a failure.
 
LouReedwalkonthewildside said:
So Ferguson saying what he did will convince people.
Click to expand...

No, it won’t necessarily convince people but it’s important for negotiations that Moshiri, Brands, Kenwright, Ferguson and anyone else at the club appear to maintain that stance.

“We’re happy to keep him, we’re in no rush to sell him” will always get you a better deal than “He’s trouble, he’s unhappy, he’s fell out with everyone and we don’t trust him in the 1st team”.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top