thebluefox
Player Valuation: £50m
mick lyons scored a header in the park end ,as good a goal you would ever see, it was dissalowed for fuk all ,they went the full lenght of the park and scored, alan fuken waddle
- Status
bluenosedave
Player Valuation: £500k
Can any statto's out there tell me how many penalties we have been awarded at Analfield throughout our history? I remember a grand total of 0.
As the result was a draw, he didn't want to have the game settled by such a mental goal. He reasoned in the split second he had that both clubs would be happy with the draw, and just blindly hoped he could think up a reason for disallowing it later.
To be fair, the linesman last week did exactly the same thing. Osman threw his hand up to claim offside, the fans behind him bellowed for it, and he decided it was easier to preserve the draw than to make a decision that may have been wrong.
They're humans at the end of the day.
One in the last 67 years.
http://www.evertonresults.com/derbypens.htm
Liverpool have had nine at Goodison.
chrismanduk
Player Valuation: £2.5m
Bad bad challenge.
Heard Nulty was gonna sue him for loss of livelihood,anybody know if he went through with it?
Hope he did and nailed the dirty red thug.
B
Beagers
Guest
Not even sure if the thug was even booked,never an apology,nothing,typical of the classless b*ggers!!
Seamus Colemole
Previously deathbyropeandglass
To me its kinda obvious.
Gerrard was through on goal, Hibbert was careless and clipped the back of his legs. Regardless of whether you think Gerard waited till he was in the area or not if the ref sees that as Hibbert tripping him through carelessness its a foul.
As he denied a clear goalscoring goal it should have been a red. If he then made the wrong decision to bring out a yellow i'd fully expect any Everton player to tell the ref that he's got the wrong card and it should be a red, and thats what Gerrard done.
A red was the correct decision and if it was the other way round and he gave one of their players a yellow when it should have been a red you'd all be furious.
Why else would he have a pulled out a yellow other than as a mistake, you can argue that Gerard shouldn't have played the ref but thats bollocks, when the ref makes crap decision you tell him and hope he makes the right one?
Steven Naismith
Player Valuation: £6m
"YOU'RE JUST BITTER AND JEALOUS LAD, WE'VE WON IT 5 TIMES" is the reaction you would get if you shown this thread to any Kopite across the globe
The clattenberg derby was just atrocious, but the whole hibbert thing is a tad overblown imo. I understand the red as gerrard was through on g oal(even tho i kinda remember hibbert got the ball first) and Hibbert was the last man. But it was outside the box. No way that was a penalty, the red i can understand tho.
Everything else was just horrific in that match tho.
Everything else was just horrific in that match tho.
EFC Si
Player Valuation: £25m
I never had a problem with this one, it's a red card all day long.
Jamo Martinez
Player Valuation: £70m
I never had any complaints about the card personally. It was the lack of a red for Kunt and the penalty we didn't get I objected to.
Had to laugh watching the derby when Howard was asking the ref (apparently) for a second yellow for Sterling. The commentator was saying that was something we don't like to see and he was sure Steve Gerrard would have a word about it. fcukwit.
Seamus Colemole
Previously deathbyropeandglass
I understand people thinking he only gave the red because gbh said he'd left him a nice fat envolope in the dressing room, but its obviously just a case of him getting the wrong card and then gbh doing what any player would do and telling the ref it should be a red and the ref then making the right decision.
Its not like he gave a red for a yellow card offense only after he had a word.
Whistlin' Dixie
Player Valuation: £50m
Surprised nobody's mentioned that rat mcallister with that free-kick about 15yards forward from where it was given 
- Status
