The Oldies Thread

We ALWAYS had fish on Good Friday, I wonder if its still a thing with families these days.

…..fish on a normal Friday is still a thing; Fish Friday. I have fish every Friday for evening meal.

I think Good Friday is more about the religious aspect of not eating meat. Mrs Eggs is a RC, today I had fresh salmon for lunch and will be having fresh cod for tea.
 
…..fish on a normal Friday is still a thing; Fish Friday. I have fish every Friday for evening meal.

I think Good Friday is more about the religious aspect of not eating meat. Mrs Eggs is a RC, today I had fresh salmon for lunch and will be having fresh cod for tea.
My late mother used to buy fresh fish from then the local green grocer & show me the lords thumb mark on the back of a certain fish was it a a John Dory before cooking it in the oven ....

1775220484355.webp
 
…..fish on a normal Friday is still a thing; Fish Friday. I have fish every Friday for evening meal.

I think Good Friday is more about the religious aspect of not eating meat. Mrs Eggs is a RC, today I had fresh salmon for lunch and will be having fresh cod for tea.
Yes, it was the religious side of things I was thinking about (not eating meat on Good Friday).
I'll be round for tea later 🤣
 
Am I the only one who never got the distinction for us catholic kids between eschewing meat on Friday's but chewing fish instead. surely god created the animals in the sea as well as on land. Fish is just sea-meat!
I am not catholic, but have always laughed at hypocrisy like that. The best one is the Scottish Island that treated puffins as fish-so they could eat them on a day such as this. (Add to that wild boars that have been determined as "not pigs" in areas of Northern Turkey so the locals can eat them).
 
a quick google reveals the entire absurdity of 'Carnis' note birds included as land animals.....

Why Is Fish Acceptable?​

Per the USCCB, the Church’s laws refer to abstaining from “land animals” only. This includes the meat from chickens, sheep, pigs, cows and other forms of livestock — any animal, really, that makes its home on land. This also includes birds. However, because fish make their home in the water, the Catholic Church does not consider fish a meat. In fact, the laws of the Church go on to explain that followers may eat “fresh and saltwater fish, reptiles, amphibians and shellfish” on Good Friday, as animals that fall into one of these categories are not “carnis.”

It’s important to note that the rules for Lent and Good Friday were developed centuries ago, when meat was the food of celebrations. Back then, fish was not considered a “celebratory” dish, and so was perfectly acceptable to eat on a day of penance.

In today’s culture, however, the opposite is usually true.
 
Am I the only one who never got the distinction for us catholic kids between eschewing meat on Friday's but chewing fish instead. surely god created the animals in the sea as well as on land. Fish is just sea-meat!
One of the many, many questions and conundrums thrown up by religions...
I've spent this holy day catching up on old Christopher Hitchens interviews and debates. Re-affirming ;)
 

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top