The Calvert-Lewin Poll

[Woolly Blue]

Yes, i know there's a thread already, but this one's got a poll and the bossman says

Feel free to start new threads regarding any new topics of discussion relating to this player - new contracts, player quotes, transfer news etc

... so here's a poll to vote on whether or not you think he's worth a new five year contract.

Mods : Please close this thread when the poll's closed in a couple of weeks, or earlier if you're so inclined.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Yes.

But let him go out on loan next year and play every week.

 

[Groucho]

I reckon we need to see him play a run of games in his preferred position before casting judgment.

 

[nsno-chris]

Koff Woolly.

In all seriousness I'm unsure, he doesn't look like he has what it takes, but I guess that's why I'm on a forum and Ronky, Walsh and Unsy make the decisions that matter

C'mon Dom

 

[LocalNative]

Think everyone is being extremely harsh on him tbh.

Young kid, plucked from lower leagues and suffered bad injury when he was playing well pre-Christmas.

Give him a chance - tell you what he's not looked worse than what we've had playing out wide the past few seasons.

 

[snipellis11]

He's sound, don't listen to the people who are slagging him off already, too daft to laugh at.

 

[Woolly Blue]

I reckon we need to see him play a run of games in his preferred position before casting judgment.

This is very true, but where's the fun in that ?

 

[Walter Ego]

Too early to say. I haven't seen anything to make me think he's either good or bad. Shouldn't really be first 11 next season from what I've seen so far though.

 

[ijjysmith]

Send to Sheff United so he can play up front properly for a year.

I'll vote this time next season.

@Woolly Blue will be a mod again by then so can reopen it himself.

 

[The Rhino]

He seems a nice lad but I don't rate him tbh. Rashford is around the same age/came onto the scene at 18/19 and looks alot better. Obviously players develop at different ages but when you look at the likes of Dolberg/Dembele/Batshuyai all around/coming onto the scene at 19/20 he doesnt match up and I couldnt imagine DCL banging 15-20 a season even in the Dutch/French league.

 

[KaiserEFC]

If he develops into a top player happy days

If he doesn't, who the hell actually cares?

Simple.

 

[diggerdestroyer]

Doesnt look the bizz at the moment. Has a bit of pace alright. Will never be able to play by himself up front and we have had 1 up front for as long long long time. He doesnt have the physique. Maybe playing up front off a target player. Going by what ive seen already im saying it look doubtful he will be a top player so needs to improve, and a lot.

 

[barneygumble]

The whole idea that a 19-year old, who's yet to make any real impact thus far, can command £40,000 a week for the next 5 years is staggering.

It could go three ways....

1. He's Gash, and we're lumbered with £2m a year for the lad for 5 years.
2. He's boss, and it's great investment
3. £40k a week for someone who was in League One playing against Yeovil, Burton and the likes last season, could send him off the rails, and ruin him.

I think it's a big risk. The management must see something most of us don't...... (possibly a forward... cause we dont see that)

 

[tommye]

Yes, i know there's a thread already, but this one's got a poll and the bossman says



... so here's a poll to vote on whether or not you think he's worth a new five year contract.

Mods : Please close this thread when the poll's closed in a couple of weeks, or earlier if you're so inclined.

Quiet night mate?

 

[degsy]

Yes.

But let him go out on loan next year and play every week.

No way, we'll need every player in that Thursday Cup thing