Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread


Do you need a hand moving the goalposts mate or are you alright on your own?

Look, if anybody has defended David Moyes on here more than I have over the last 10 years I'll be amazed, so you don't need to try and be his white knight against me. All i'm saying is it's just undeniable that his record away at the top sides is poor, it doesn't make him a bad manager and i'm not saying that 48000 other managers have done better, i'm just saying it's a poor record and trying to pretend like it isn't (and that other people are thick for thinking it is) is stupid.
You get one post...I'll get the other.
 
Show me manager who's got a good record against "Top sides"....ones that have managed in the Premier League as long as Moyes has?

It's arl stick used to beat Moyes with,it's a lazy comment void of any sort of critical thinking,trotted out by the Anti Moyes brigade.

How many managers have beat Fulham,Palace, Brighton and Forest away this season?

The mid table managers who have a good record against the top sides are the same managers who are losing badly at home to other mid table teams regularly. If they beat all the sides below them and regularly beat the top sides then they’d be flying at the top of the league.

It’s the balance equation that too many fans just don’t seem to understand. The very counterattacking high press football that might get a team a win at Stamford Bridge or the Emirates is also the exact sort of football that might see you lose 4-0 at home to a bottom 3 team, or perhaps get absolutely caned by your local rival on your own patch. Everton fans would never accept that type of result.

Equally Moyes in his first period with us built a team that could get on the ball, hold possession, build up play, and create chances through Baines Pienaar Osman Arteta Cahill Yakubu etc. It meant we could outplay lesser teams at Goodison quite easily at times in a manner not seen since but the challenge is it’s very difficult to play this way and dominate top teams away from home.

If you want a team that can do both we need players that can play with the ball but also have the pace and power to play without it and counter at top teams. Those players cost serious money, money Everton haven’t had for about 28 of the last 30 seasons.
 
I meant in Moyes' first spell rather than now. There are a lot more teams above us these days!!
Don't think we should expect any different this time. If we beat the teams we should at home and get away wins at the eventual bottom 4-6 teams that should get us around the duff European Conference position and that's really his level. I'd be happy enough with that.
 
Don't think we should expect any different this time. If we beat the teams we should at home and get away wins at the eventual bottom 4-6 teams that should get us around the duff European Conference position and that's really his level. I'd be happy enough with that.
5 home wins this season or something like that. Big "if" !!
 

The mid table managers who have a good record against the top sides are the same managers who are losing badly at home to other mid table teams regularly. If they beat all the sides below them and regularly beat the top sides then they’d be flying at the top of the league.

It’s the balance equation that too many fans just don’t seem to understand. The very counterattacking high press football that might get a team a win at Stamford Bridge or the Emirates is also the exact sort of football that might see you lose 4-0 at home to a bottom 3 team, or perhaps get absolutely caned by your local rival on your own patch. Everton fans would never accept that type of result.

Equally Moyes in his first period with us built a team that could get on the ball, hold possession, build up play, and create chances through Baines Pienaar Osman Arteta Cahill Yakubu etc. It meant we could outplay lesser teams at Goodison quite easily at times in a manner not seen since but the challenge is it’s very difficult to play this way and dominate top teams away from home.

If you want a team that can do both we need players that can play with the ball but also have the pace and power to play without it and counter at top teams. Those players cost serious money, money Everton haven’t had for about 28 of the last 30 seasons.
I think that's a slightly different argument. Obviously if you're midtable then by definition your results are going to be mixed, but I don't think it's necessarily as clear cut as the style of play suiting one type of game but not another.

Both Everton as a club and Moyes as a manager do seem to have a real problem going away to the 'big' clubs. It's weird, I can't explain it, but it's undoubtedly a thing. Moyes has won 0 out of 20 visits to Stamford Bridge in the league, and we as a club haven't won there for 33 years, but Brentford under Thomas Frank have beaten them 3 times in 4 years since they came up. That's just bonkers and we desperately need to find a way to change those patterns. Hopefully this transfer window can be the start of doing that.
 
5 home wins this season or something like that. Big "if" !!
I didn't expect much with the squad he inherited. He put one together last time that did just that. Can he do it again? With decent financial backing you'd think so. I don't expect too much. Losses in single figures would do me.
 

I think that's a slightly different argument. Obviously if you're midtable then by definition your results are going to be mixed, but I don't think it's necessarily as clear cut as the style of play suiting one type of game but not another.

Both Everton as a club and Moyes as a manager do seem to have a real problem going away to the 'big' clubs. It's weird, I can't explain it, but it's undoubtedly a thing. Moyes has won 0 out of 20 visits to Stamford Bridge in the league, and we as a club haven't won there for 33 years, but Brentford under Thomas Frank have beaten them 3 times in 4 years since they came up. That's just bonkers and we desperately need to find a way to change those patterns. Hopefully this transfer window can be the start of doing that.

I like Moyes as a manager he done incredibly well in his shoestring budget, but I have to agree with Lanolin on this, it was knives to a gunfight, Moyes never done as well as he should have against the top sides. As I remember we were not far off them with some of the teams he made, I personally felt we should have sent after them more, we would probably have had more defeats but I feel more victories as well if we had.
 
I like Moyes as a manager he done incredibly well in his shoestring budget, but I have to agree with Lanolin on this, it was knives to a gunfight, Moyes never done as well as he should have against the top sides. As I remember we were not far off them with some of the teams he made, I personally felt we should have sent after them more, we would probably have had more defeats but I feel more victories as well if we had.
When DM was manager in the past his transfer budget was nearly always tiny, very often depending on sales to allow for purchases.

It isn't that he will have unlimited funds now but we should have more access to money with the new stadium and new owners.
 
It’s not just Moyes with the terrible record away at top sides - it’s the club generally. It hasn’t improved one iota since Moyes left (empty stadiums notwithstanding)

The mentality at the club needs to change along with all the other changes this summer.
 

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top