Stephen Carr?

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's just it, I don't think we do want a right back. I also think that if Phil Neville played there all the time and never had to venture into a depleted midfield to play alongside Carsley then we'd see a whole different player to the one who's become the whipping boy this season.
 

That's just it, I don't think we do want a right back. I also think that if Phil Neville played there all the time and never had to venture into a depleted midfield to play alongside Carsley then we'd see a whole different player to the one who's become the whipping boy this season.

I wouldn't argue with that.

I'd say midfield is first priority and then RB if the right opportunity presents itself.
 
Paul Scharner would be a decent pickup but I believe his happy with the Latics. Neville has to be the #1 RB and never have to grace midfield again even if injuries are common.
 
Paul Scharner would be a decent pickup but I believe his happy with the Latics. Neville has to be the #1 RB and never have to grace midfield again even if injuries are common.

But you know our ever so brilliant manager is so in love with him he will never look past that and ignore the fact Neville is [Poor language removed] in midfield and it damages our team greatly to play him there.

Nope, gotta have his favourite boy on the pitch at all costs.
 

We definitely need a midfielder, as i think in defence we have enough cover, for me we need a carsley replacement i would love barry, i know he wouldn't leave villa and would be top dollar, but a great player and plays the holding role for england well.
 
i think we would be crackers to sign carr.

free or not he is gonna want paying and probably too much for my liking.
also he hasnt done wonders at newcastle so why would he be any different here ?

yobo , jags , neville , hibbert , gosling and i think irving can all play right back.
i wouldnt sell yobo or jags , gosling and irving are fringe players we know nothing about , which leaves hibbert and neville the only 2 candidates to be replaced. both have lacked in certain aspects to there game but id still say both will be much better to have in the team at the start of next season than stephen carr.

if we are gonna replace both or one of them then please let it be a much younger player and better quality than a clapped out over weight midget from the premier reject bargain bin !

but imo we do need to build on top of what we have in a couple of areas ..

rb ...nevllle/or/hibbert
wing .....pienarr/osman
cm .....carsley

im not saying we should sell piennar osman and carsley but we should definatly buy 1 winger and 1 cm of better quality than them who can take there place in the starting lineup.
we do also need a better quality right back but that would mean we would definatly have to sell either hibbert or neville.

add to that list a striker to compete with yak and aj and the team should be nice for next season.

Scharner barry kranjcar and dare i say it ... crouch. might suit our needs nicely.
 
i too agree i dont think we need to go near carr he best is behind him and hes a grumpy little git :P

i ve read crouch been mentioned personally i do not wanna see us go near anyone tall as a striker we dont have a " passing" mentality in the squad so it would be pretty painful on the eye to see aerial attact after aerial attack for 40+ games a yr

though we are gradually gettin better ...arteta, pienaar, fernandes,.....
 

Personally i would like to see Carr ive watched him for years play for Ireland and he is a quality full back certainly better then what we currently have, hes played at the highest level in World Cups etc and would add a different dimension to our attacking play form full back, with him and Baines on either side we would have our two attacking full backs!

I think we are being a littel to quick on tese pages to write of players recently!(y)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top