Should Coleman be Ushered out?

[OzyToffee]

he was MoM the game before last.

 

[Archie Knox]

One million percent yes. Was a great player for us and should rightly earn a testimonial once he's retired. But his best is long gone unfortunately.

 

[Lelouch]

can't be first choice this season

the only thing coleman offers is bouncing over to the ref when something happens, but that's not a reason to play

haven't seen enough of Sidibe to say that tbh

 

[evertonarntwe]

haven't seen enough of Sidibe to say that tbh

same

but I've seen enough of coleman to know he isn't the answer

 

[little elfin]

TBH I don't like his passing, crossing, stubborn dribbling and some defending.
It's okay when he made direct and messy runs but still he is not in the same level as Baines for attacking fullback.

 

[Baines' left foot]

He’s performing like a £60k player alright.

 

[Zatara]

Have to hope that (like Digne last season) Sidibe takes his opportunity now.

It could even be that Coleman needs to be given more time to recover between games.

Sidibe is far more attacking and so he should be starting at the moment...perhaps against those sides who will put us on the back foot Coleman plays.

 

[gianthogweed]

He would struggle to get in a mid table team but seen as we are not a mid table team he will do just fine

 

[blueblue]

Getting found out a bit now, still good getting forward, his final ball has always mainly been piss poor, 31 in a few days, so we should be looking for his replacement at the end of the season.

I think he may be in the German league this season.

 

[Eggs]

....strange thread, the Manager has been quite open about his search for a new RB.

 

[Grinch]

I honestly think Sidibe should get a nod going forward until proven otherwise. I like the prospect of little jon-joe coming back as the Prodigal Son to save the day. With sidibe option to buy for 14M, could be worth the while. Seems like Captain has lost his step a bit and struggles to get back on defense with the counter. I love Coleman but it may be time.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Yes

But I don't know if Sidibe is better.

 

[Death]

That is some serious thought and energy put into our under par RB. When the manager situation is so much bigger and a proper manager would make this decision for us without us needing to speculate.

 

[Tubey]

Yes, but you don't seemlessly replace a player as good as he has been overnight very often.

Digne replacing Baines is a fluke bit of luck - that isn't the norm.

 

[blueblue]

Based on performances this season I think the same argument could be made about replacing every player in the team week after week.

A couple of wins, confidence returning , a new manager and suddenly they could start to look like very good players again.

The question is why they all look like such poor players just now.