Should Big Dunc stay as interim till summer?

allen · December 10, 2019

dholliday said:
i think he's a funny interesting character, but he never should've got near our club.

I had no problem with him until he became our manager. He never made an effort with the fans.

APN_EFC · December 10, 2019

I dont mean to jump on the back of the one-off win on Saturday, but unless we get a manager who is the type who will really turn things around quickly, what's the harm in sticking with him till Summer
If he's survived 4 managers as assistant, he's either good as an assistant, or he's not, and what if he's actually a much better manager than he was a player. IT seems like if he doesn't get the end of the season job now, he'll never be a manager anywhere.

John Barton · December 10, 2019

blue61 said:
Get that Reidy lad back from Wigan to help Dunc and get a boss manager in the summer. Let there be blood.

Please god no,
when will people ever learn that our mid 80s team spirit was instilled by Andy Gray and not another failed Sunderland manager

Deleted member 48881 · December 10, 2019

we are close to %40 now with the yes votes, public is getting warmed up to the idea, good.

Yarrgh · December 10, 2019

[Deleted Member] said:
we are close to %40 now with the yes votes, public is getting warmed up to the idea, good.

The more I think about it, the more I would like to give him a run. He has 2 stinkers in United away and Leicester in the cup which require a bit more of the same as we saw on Saturday. I'd be happy to see that against them so would not be upset if he had the next 2 games.

If we saw a little guile thrown into the mix ... I'd not be adverse to a longer time in charge. He's not Simeone, but he has that hardness about him that I want in the Everton manager. He's far from the job at the moment, but if he keeps getting results and no one else is in the running, why not keep him in charge.

Tipp blue · December 11, 2019

I've finally made my mind up on this poll, keep him till summer, and see how things are going, we are not going to get relegated and we're not going to crash the top 4, and there is no manager being mentioned that will get Goodison rocking like it was V Chelsea, that does rub off on the players every one of them upped their game even Schneiderlin looked much better. Leave Dunc in it's just crazy enough to work.

davek · December 11, 2019

lol

People bricking it over getting Moyes in and wanting to hurtle over a cliff with a coach with no managerial experience in a season we need to get through and avoid relegation.

Just no.

Bazlar · December 11, 2019

If the rumours are true about who else is available I would stick with him and see how it goes

Tipp blue · December 11, 2019

davek said:
lol

People bricking it over getting Moyes in and wanting to hurtle over a cliff with a coach with no managerial experience in a season we need to get through and avoid relegation.

Just no.

I am 100% convinced that there is no team in the PL that would have came away with anything from Goodison last week in Dunc's first game, he's earned a second game in charge a result away to United and there should be no doubts about him staying on until a good realistic option becomes available, under Ferguson we won't be relegated we'll win the majority of home games, and with the no nonsense 4-4-2 I would expect to see an improvement away too.

davek · December 11, 2019

Tipp blue said:
I am 100% convinced that there is no team in the PL that would have came away with anything from Goodison last week in Dunc's first game, he's earned a second game in charge a result away to United and there should be no doubts about him staying on until a good realistic option becomes available, under Ferguson we won't be relegated we'll win the majority of home games, and with the no nonsense 4-4-2 I would expect to see an improvement away too.

He hasn't coached a game yet mate. Not one. Bt you'd hand our existence as a PL club over to him.

Toffeelover · December 11, 2019

davek said:
He hasn't coached a game yet mate. Not one. Bt you'd hand our existence as a PL club over to him.

BS Dave, Tippblue only suggested as an interim.

Pittsburgh Footy · December 11, 2019

Why do we have to let him have the side until end of season? Or announce anything? Can't we just continue on as is until we find someone suitable? Arsenal sacked Emery before we sacked Silva and they still have an interim manager. There's no risk to doing this, just biding our time. In theory, playing a spirited old school 4-4-2 should keep us grabbing enough points to stay comfortably out of a relegation battle while we look for a manager to take us forward.

4737carlin · December 11, 2019

Pittsburgh Footy said:
Why do we have to let him have the side until end of season? Or announce anything? Can't we just continue on as is until we find someone suitable? Arsenal sacked Emery before we sacked Silva and they still have an interim manager. There's no risk to doing this, just biding our time. In theory, playing a spirited old school 4-4-2 should keep us grabbing enough points to stay comfortably out of a relegation battle while we look for a manager to take us forward.

Yeah some want to rush into it, i know Spurs did but they 100% had Jose first, Everton dont plan ahead like that, no reason why Dunc cant have 3 or 4 games

Tipp blue · December 11, 2019

davek said:
He hasn't coached a game yet mate. Not one. Bt you'd hand our existence as a PL club over to him.

Our players are better than they have been playing, we have alot of confidence players probably too many who'll turn to $hit with the crowd on their backs, I don't care who the manager is, we could have the best manager in the world but if goodison is not cooperating the players will be gash, as far as I can see Ferguson nullifies that aspect, our players need confidence and they need the fans all the experience as a manager doesn't guarantee that.