In the main I think he's done a good job this year, but I think we need to face a few home truths.
For all the talk of him being 'ruthless', there's an awful lot of players who have been allowed to continue being at best average but getting picked every week. For all the talk of him being the mythical 'winner' we have been knocked out of both cups early, and our record away at the sides above has seen us (somehow) pick up 1 point, scoring 4 and conceding 12. Not exactly a seismic shift from previous years.
As I say, he's doing ok but there's an awful lot of room for improvement.