Poor, Average, Good: Rate Our Players

[Hellerad]

Only three poor players after today's performance?

Preseason. Against Arsenal.

Our problem is too many average players. Average teams don't finish top 6.

 

[Caolam]

I'm a bit concerned we might be proving " the whole is better than the sum of its parts" to be wrong

 

[COYB]

boss


Besic

 

[degsy]

It's often said that Everton have some good players, some poor, and some average – but which are which? Let's find out.

Poor
Howard
Robles
Hibbert
McGeady
Naismith
Kone

Average
Gibson
Jagielka
Oviedo
Lukaku
Cleverley
Barry
Deulofeu
Osman
Pienaar
Barkley
Garbutt

Good
Baines
Stones
Coleman
McCarthy
Mirallas
Besic

I might've put Naismith into the average block...but other than that.

 

[Saint Domingo]

Dear god.

When has besic earned to be in the good group?

Plus Howard is not poor.

Just melted my mind here.. Staggering.

Howard is poor. Woeful keeper,

 

[Gwladys St. Glory]

Average
@Joey66
@Pantocoyb
@Brownie
@Elong
@Gwladys St. Glory
@BlueLlama
@beachy
@LABlue2
@Little Ralphy
@Scolari
@ToffeeDan

 

[Michaelcoyb]

Kone is somewhere between poor and amateur. That header went into row z!

 

[tadpole]

what a nasty thread

 

[deipnosophist]

Kone and Naisy are the players I rate

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Absolutely Terrible:

Naismith
Osman
Howard
Naismith Again
McGeady
Naismith

Boss:

Baines
Stones
Jagielka
Lukaku
McCarthy
T-Clevz

The rest are all average.

 

[USABlue]

Absolutely Terrible:

Naismith
Osman
Howard
Naismith Again
McGeady
Naismith

Boss:

Baines
Stones
Jagielka
Lukaku
McCarthy
T-Clevz

The rest are all average.

we had our best runs when osman played last year....

 

[toffeejack]

Aye I'd say he's not too bad, but he had to go in the "poor" category for the sake of my spread yah no.

EDIT: I'm judging him as a deep midfielder/winger here as that's where he usually plays. As a no. 10 (cringe) I'd maybe even have him edging towards the good category. Criminal that he doesn't get more of a game there in my opinion.

He was one of our best players last season which says just how terrible we were, but yeah I wouldn't play him any other position, which means if we do get A playmaker he will be in the terrible category.

 

[ianefc]

Just a thought are you a hypocrite if you think we have a good portion of 'good players' and also back Martinez.

As I can't see how that can be the case.

 

[Joey66]

Yes I am a kind of average guy so were does the poster see himself in the brilliant section of posters?

 

[DualityNSNO]

Kone and Naisy are the players I rate

As what?