Poor, Average, Good: Rate Our Players

[Elong]

I asked him nicely and he put him in good, deal with it.

Good for Norwich good?

 

[Goat]

Good for Norwich good?

Oh youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu.

HOWZAT

 

[Gwladys St. Glory]

So good he can't nail down a starting spot over Cleverly...

 

[BlueLlama]

Can't believe all you no marks putting Lukaku as average.

clueless

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Poor
Howard
Robles
Hibbert
McGeady
Naismith
Kone

Average
Gibson
Oviedo
Barry
Osman
Pienaar

Good
Baines
Stones
Coleman
McCarthy
Mirallas
Besic
Lukaku
Cleverley
Jagielka
Deulofeu
Barkley
Garbutt

The ones in the good list I wouldn't want to see sold, either because I think they're good or because I expect them to come good. The average ones can do a job but I wouldn't cry if they left. The poor ones can all do one really. Probably get a decent fee for Naismith, and while I quite like him he's not all that good at togger if we're being honest.

 

[Goat]

Can't believe all you no marks putting Lukaku as average.

clueless

Lazy.

 

[beachy]

Somehow Leon Osman has become the most important player at the club.

Honestly our play has been complete dirge unless he is on.

 

[LABlue2]

Not good
Besic

 

[Little Ralphy]

It's often said that Everton have some good players, some poor, and some average – but which are which? Let's find out.

Poor
Howard
Robles
Hibbert
McGeady
Naismith
Kone

Average
Gibson
Jagielka
Oviedo
Lukaku
Cleverley
Barry
Deulofeu
Osman
Pienaar
Barkley
Garbutt

Good
Baines
Stones
Coleman
McCarthy
Mirallas
Besic

Lol at anyone being above Lukaku!

Really poor
Naismith
Kone
McGeady

Poor
Oviedo
Barry
Pienaar
Robles
Gibson (never fit)

Average
Osman
Hibbert
Howard
Cleverly
Besic
Garbutt
McCarthy

Good
Barkley
Mirallas
Coleman
Jagielka
Stones
Baines

Too good for us
Lukaku

 

[Scolari]

Good:
Coleman
Jagielka
Stones
Baines
Besic
McCarthy
Cleverly
Barkley
Deulefeu
Mirallas
Lukaku

Potentially good:
Browning
Garbutt
McAleny

Injury Prone:
Oviedo
Gibson
Pienaar

Past it:
Howard
Barry
Hibbert
Osman

Not good enough:
Kone
Naismith
McGeady
Robles

 

[ToffeeDan]

Poor
Robles -- hasn't got a clue
McGready - pace and no product
Garbutt - sorry, not good enough

Average
Hibbert - what do you expect for a back-up full back at his age?
Oviedo - just that
Kone - will we ever find out tho? I'm not sure he's up for it
Naismith - certainly work hard for the team tho. (bordering on good)
Howard - was good but not so much these days (clearly the best we have in goal atm)

Good
Gibson - if only he was fit now and then
Jags - won't let you down, yellow card record tells you he doesn't get caught out often
Lukaku - has "something" but still not convinced we use him correctly
Mirallas - good for most of the 60 minute cameos we see him
Besic - but needs to work on his game
Barry - good if he doesn't have to play every game
Delo - got to work on his final ball
Osman - if a little bit past his best (heading towards average)
Pienaar - ditto to Osman (heading towards average, can still cut it if not kicked off the pitch (especially away from home where he is frequently targeted))
Coleman - another one who needs to work out that final ball

Very Good
Baines- of course
Stones - cut out some defensive lapses and he'll be one of the best
McCartney - of course
Barkley - but only if he works on not trying to do it all himself

Jury Out
Cleverley, Galloway and Browning (impressed with these two so far tho'), McAleny

 

[Chang Elephant]

 

[USABlue]

Poor
Robles
Hibbert
McGeady
Kone

Average
Gibson
Howard
Jagielka
Oviedo
Cleverley
Barry
Deulofeu
Osman
Pienaar
Barkley
Garbutt
Besic
Naismith

Good
Baines
Stones
Coleman
McCarthy
Mirallas
Lukaku

 

[Tigger]

Some serious dribble in this thread. . And that is not the players listed BTW

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

Poor
Robles -- hasn't got a clue
McGready - pace and no product
Garbutt - sorry, not good enough

Average
Hibbert - what do you expect for a back-up full back at his age?
Oviedo - just that
Kone - will we ever find out tho? I'm not sure he's up for it
Naismith - certainly work hard for the team tho. (bordering on good)
Howard - was good but not so much these days (clearly the best we have in goal atm)

Good
Gibson - if only he was fit now and then
Jags - won't let you down, yellow card record tells you he doesn't get caught out often
Lukaku - has "something" but still not convinced we use him correctly
Mirallas - good for most of the 60 minute cameos we see him
Besic - but needs to work on his game
Barry - good if he doesn't have to play every game
Delo - got to work on his final ball
Osman - if a little bit past his best (heading towards average)
Pienaar - ditto to Osman (heading towards average, can still cut it if not kicked off the pitch (especially away from home where he is frequently targeted))
Coleman - another one who needs to work out that final ball

Very Good
Baines- of course
Stones - cut out some defensive lapses and he'll be one of the best
McCartney - of course
Barkley - but only if he works on not trying to do it all himself

Jury Out
Cleverley, Galloway and Browning (impressed with these two so far tho'), McAleny

How do you know Garbutt isn't good enough?