Player of the season 2014/15

[SH1958]

At the moment between Lukaku & Naismith for me with important goals which at the end of the season will keep us up.
Without them we would be in the same position as Leicester

 

[Christiffa25]

Jesus that is really hard....

If I was pushed I'd just go Jags. Who under difficult circumstances has still played well most the time.

Up until the penalty fiasco and in turn martinez making him a part time player I would of said mirallas.

Tip of the hat goes to besic too. Very promising debut season.

 

[bitter-no-better]

Lukaku. By a mile.

 

[craigw]

I have gone for Coleman and McCarthy.

 

[banno]

Lukaku and Stones. I know stones has been injured for a good while but those others who have not been injured have not impressed me enough.

 

[Connor]

No Joel ? Outrageous.

Getting my real vote like #Joel4POTY

 

[Jimboefc97]

I think its got to be Naismith. Although he may not be the best player in the world his work rate and effort has been second to none and he's come up with a lot of goals this season.
A close second would be Lukaku but I think Naismith just edges it

 

[sageyefc]

Forza Joel

 

[ijjysmith]

 

[Eric Djemba-Djemba]

I have gone for Coleman and McCarthy.

Coleman? He's been turd this season.

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Naismith as worst 'player' of the season, Rom as our best

 

[kithnou]

I voted for Howard...like President Obama ("Timmy's our Secretary of Defence") would have. The latter is the leader of the free world, a Nobel peace Prize winner and who is almost singlehandedly keeping Poroshenko's democratically elected govt of Ukraine free from the neo-Nazism of Putin's Russia....anyone in doubt of this just needs to look at records of Hillary's emails ....errrr, hang on...

to borrow @Dutch Toffee's gem...

 

[Tree13]

To early to decided on this with still a lot to play for.

But up until the last half dozen or so games the standout player was obviously Mirallas, I doubt he'll win a popularity contest like this at the moment though.

I would agree there. One failing I would say we have as a collective fanbase is that we turn on players very quickly for any mistake. The penalty fiasco, bad as it was, has been well overblown.

Its a bit early for this but maybe some of our players could restore reputations by taking us all the way in the europa cup.Naismith gets my vote which means some of our players should be embarrassed about the season so far

Spot on. Naisy is a fair shout - you know he will always give 110%

I shudder to think where we'd be without Lukaku this season
He's been poor at times
But that's expected from a 21 year old
Easily him

On statistics, you'd have to agree it's Rom. Take his goals away and we'd be in the relegation zone.

At the moment between Lukaku & Naismith for me with important goals which at the end of the season will keep us up.
Without them we would be in the same position as Leicester

Spot on.

I think its got to be Naismith. Although he may not be the best player in the world his work rate and effort has been second to none and he's come up with a lot of goals this season.
A close second would be Lukaku but I think Naismith just edges it

For me it's the other way around, but yours is a perfectly reasonable call.



I'd go for Romelu myself, with Naismith and Mirallas tied in second place. Without Rom we'd be in the drop zone, no question. We're only three points above it now!

If Kev had Stevie's heart and work ethic, he'd be a £20m player; if Stevie had Kev's talent he'd also be a £20m player. Martinez plays Stevie out of position regularly and he also subs Kev off way too often, but they are our second and third top scorers despite this.

McCarthy has been solid but not spectacular - he needs to start putting in some decent forward passes or carrying the ball forward more. Besic would merit consideration if he got more game time; Stones has the talent but needs to impose himself more and start dominating games.

Coleman, Baines, Barry and Barkley are shadows of the players they were last year. Jags has been overall mediocre, and was very, very poor from week one until about Christmas.

Well done to McGeady for convincing his wife and parents to log in and vote.

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Voted for Baines cos he didn't have a vote and I love him

 

[Jxg]

Well, the season isn't anywhere near over yet so great thread