Our top 3.

[GwladysBlue]

1. Stones
2. McCarthy
3. Lukaku

 

[Yorkie]

Stones,
Lukaku,
Jagielka.

It's actually a hard atm, not enough of them standing above the rest all this season.

 

[marty mcfly]

It's actually a hard atm, not enough of them standing above the rest all this season.

Or consistently playing well enough.

 

[Yorkie]

Or consistently playing well enough.

Stones was the most consistent, bar an unlucky injury. Hence hes most poster's #1.

 

[Shibbywiggles]

Stones
McCarthy
Lukaku
Coleman

These are our biggest assets who should never be sold!

We've played well without Baines when Oviedo covered last season and we've played well without Mirallas plenty of times but we have never put in a good performance under Martinez without Lukaku or McCarthy (barring when we beat a terrible QPR side with Besic/Barkley).

 

[Moomin]

Garbutt
Distin
Mirallas

 

[marty mcfly]

Stones was the most consistent, bar an unlucky injury. Hence hes most poster's #1.

Stones has had a few howlers too. We just don't make a big deal of it. McCarthy, Coleman, Baines and Jags are also pretty consistent if you exclude injuries. Barry was consistent once he got up to speed (January) after the summer however certain games don't suit him. McGeady and Naismith are just annoyingly consistently inconsistent. Barkley seemed to only play well in the games he could be assed in. Lukaku was similar but is a beast when he gets going. Mirallas was bi-polar. Howard in fairness did well after coming back from injury. Osman is Osman - same performance every week (7/10).

But none where guaranteed 7.5/10 every game except for Baines.

 

[TheFinnFan]

1. FUQ
2. OFF
3. KENWRIGHT

Unique response x

 

[applecrumble]

This season its tough:

1.) Kit man.
2.) Tea Lady.
3.) Stones.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

McCarthy
Stones
Lukaku

Interesting nobody has put Barkley

 

[Stephenlloyd]

McCarthy
Stones
Lukaku

Interesting nobody has put Barkley

McCarthy our best player last year
The mind [Poor language removed] boggles
He was bang average prior to Xmas

And wasn't much better in the 2nd half

I said on the barkley thread

If bids of 25mil came in for them both in the summer abd we had to sell one

It would be McCarthy every day for me

Schniderlin is a much better player

 

[Furey1878]

1. Naismith
2. Naismith
3. Naismith

 

[chicoazul]

It's all about opinions
He didn't make prem team of the year
And him and jags weren't that great on the biggest stage last summer

Hitler was not all that bad really.

 

[Eggs]

1. Stones
2. McCarthy
3. Lukaku

.....not surpring, the ones we would get most money for.

 

[Woolly Blue]

In terms of importance to the team :-

Lukaku
Baines and
Osman

In terms of value

Lukaku
McCarthy and
Stones

I'd love to put Ross in either of those, but can't at the moment.