Our best scottish player (in modern times)

[Blue_in_london]

what about Mo Johnson?

 

[toffeestillidie]

gotta say gary naysmith!

seriously though big dunc is my favourite based on his pride and spirit, but skill wise i'd say sharpe (haven't seen all that much of him, i'm still pretty young, but all the highlights and games from before that i've seen, i've liked) or maybe even Faddy for his miracle goals, once in a blue moon is often enough for me.

 

[bluesb1970]

I don't think many on this website can remember Alex Young so he can't really be expected to win this. For me there is only one winner................................................................................................"He got behind Lawrenson did Sharp..."
What else do i need to say?

 

[daz4matty]

For me sharpy then andy gray then dunc then davie weir

 

[atrottel]

For me sharpy then andy gray then dunc then davie weir

That'll do for me as well...

 

[Sim]

Without a shadow of a doubt for me, from the 90's onwards, its the mighty Duncan Ferguson!

 

[Sharpys top lip]

Easy that one......ME,sharpy by far are best scot!!

 

[Chill125]

Going to take this to mention my great uncle Jimmy Dunn who scored 49 goals in 135 appearance's but he played between 1928 - 1935.
In recent years Dunc's status takes some beating but for me Sharp was not only a stand out in our team but in the league as a whole.

 

[blogman]

joe..joe....joe joe.... harper !?

i thought joe harper was great........but then i saw him play
sharp.....followed by gray......then the golden vision.........dunc became a great legend before he became a great player

 

[blaggerblue]

gough wasnt here for long but he was fantastic.

 

[CanadaToffee]

As i already said, Sharpy, but if Gray had been with the club a few extra years...perhaps there'd be no debate.

 

[coyney]

If it was all time Alex Young and Jimmy Gabriel would be high on the list sharpy too but in modern age Weir has to be top cost coppers never any thing but professional I cant pick Dunc simply because he seemed to miss more than he played and his silly antics getting him sent off,

 

[SuitsBlue]

how was i so silly to miss it...

David Moyes

initially had to play manager on a shoestring and conjour a side capable of fighting for prem survival, then had to fool the everton chosen into believing the truth, that suddenly everton had a side worthy of note.

since then there has been no magic, illusion or con, we have a side that is prepared to push for the top, prepared to fight, prepared to dare for the heights of yesteryear.

moyes our greatest scotsman, of that there is no doubt.

 

[McBain]

yeh but hes not a player.

Unless by not reading pages 2 and 3 ive missed something!