This doesn't make sense
Why sell siggy (at a loss) and vlasic just starting to make a name for himself
To buy a zggy/vlasic type player?
- Status
Why sell siggy (at a loss) and vlasic just starting to make a name for himself
To buy a zggy/vlasic type player?
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
Im not saying that...the workflow would be;
A-- Would Brands/Silva have signed sigurdsson for £40mil+ ?
B -- If the answer is no then would they sell him in order to bring in a player who Silva felt would fit into his system better?
C-- If the answer is yes then how much would they want for him...?
Then it leads to the same questions for Vlasic and Dowell.
What im saying is, we have 3 attacking central midfielders...all have strengths and weaknesses...some may suit Brands/Silva in different ways e.g starting/rotation/resale etc
I think they will have an eye on Sigurdssons age (approaching 30) and Vlasic/Dowell being u21 and each have their own reasons to keep or sell.
Thats a fairly hefty transfer pot generated by selling at least 2 of those players...
Frang
Player Valuation: £70m
He gets very confused.
He looks at that many player he stays he starts combining players together.
He must be a sagittarius or gemini..
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
CRIMHEAD
Player Valuation: £40m
They would go for Sigurdsson because he's a much better player than Vlasic. No way and I mean NO WAY Sigurdsson gets sold for 30M. No way. Even if he were to get sold, they sure as heck wouldn't count on Vlasic to be his replacement. That would be insane.
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
Its insane to think Marcel Brands would pay £40mil+ for Gylfi Sigurdsson.
How much would you think is an acceptable fee for a player turning 30 in september?
CRIMHEAD
Player Valuation: £40m
First of all, that's not the situation. Brands inherited Sigurdsson, so your premise is irrelevant. Second of all, in the CURRENT situation, there's no way he'd sell Sigurdsson even for 40M and rely on Vlasic to be our #10 this year or next. No way. There is a massive gap between those two players.
Don't get me wrong, I like Vlasic, happy that he's doing well, and if we bring him back over the summer and want to give him a shot at the backup 10, that's fine.
They wouldn’t pay £40m for Sig but luckily someone did it for them.
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
Im not sure how that is a response to my post?
You stated that of Vlasic (€9mil), Dowell (youth) and Sigurdsson (£44mil) Brands/Silva would go for Sigurdsson.
You stated that it was insane not to go for him
I responded by saying they wouldnt and that its insane to think so.
If you think Sigurdsson wouldnt be sold for £40mil then...i think thats incorrect.
Hes not a player chosen by either the manager or DOF and no way worth £40mil...
£40mil for someone turning 30 in september How i wish Brands had £40mil instead.
Stephenlloyd
Player Valuation: £40m
The only way I can see siggurdsson being sold isIm not sure how that is a response to my post?
You stated that of Vlasic (€9mil), Dowell (youth) and Sigurdsson (£44mil) Brands/Silva would go for Sigurdsson.
You stated that it was insane not to go for him
I responded by saying they wouldnt and that its insane to think so.
If you think Sigurdsson wouldnt be sold for £40mil then...i think thats incorrect.
Hes not a player chosen by either the manager or DOF and no way worth £40mil...
How i wish Brands had £40mil instead.
1) someone coming in and offering good money
2) if silva wants to play a different system
433, which I think is the system he prefers. Without a recognised number 10.
Do they keep him in the team for another couple of years and at 32 be left with a player that wouldn’t fetch much money. Or sell this summer for a decent fee.
I doubt Brands will ever spend big on a 28yr old
@Zatara you said that you think Sig would be sold for £30m. Someone disagreed and now you’ve just turned it into a debate over whether brands and silva would now pay £40m for Sig, when the circumstances are cleary much different from when we did get him.
On the point the other poster actually seemed to take issue with, I agree and don’t think Sig would be sold for £30m
On the point the other poster actually seemed to take issue with, I agree and don’t think Sig would be sold for £30m
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
Spot on.
Read back mate...i asked if Sigurdsson would be bought by Brands for £40mil + also he wrote that he believed he would be...
Initially id written Brands would take £30mil which he later said he didnt believe brands would sell for £40mil
stannyr
Player Valuation: £1m
End of the day, he could have sat on our bench all season and gained nothing but he has gone to a competitive European side, been a star player for them and last night gone toe to toe with Isco.
This is the sort of loan move we'd never previously make and capitalize on so I'm hoping Brands is even more of a genius than we thought.
This is the sort of loan move we'd never previously make and capitalize on so I'm hoping Brands is even more of a genius than we thought.
mightymoyes
Player Valuation: £70m
messymascot
Player Valuation: £35m
Personally I would keep him if he understands initially he would be on the bench and it would be down to him to force his way in. If we have Europa he would start these games as he has more experience of different styles of football. If he was impressive in these games he would be given chances in the league if our starting player came off the boil. As for Sigurdsson I would sell in a heartbeat if someone came in with £25-30 million. He is currently one of our top 3 important players but he is like the girl with the curl. If we get a top striker and a wide right who also contributes his goals become less important. If he goes we could possible manage without replacing him as we would have Bernard, Vlasic, Lookman and Dowell as options.
- Status
