Mate, I've never seen the club win a trophy and being in the top flight is a pretty low bar to use as sentiment - it's essentially being a "happy to be there" club.
Goodison is horrendous, yes it looks good to the "what a classic stadium crowd", the facilities are horrendous, most of the views (apart from top balc and upper bullens without posts) are tragic.
A river side stadium with first class facilities, as well as being closer to the city centre has people like myself extremely excited to move there.
Part of our debts are surely due to Goodison being inadequate for a team that wants to challenge.
Goodison has a lot of memories for people but it has to go, and you need to let it go my friend.
Yes, we know Goodison's obvious inadequacies. That's the same self fulfilling prophecy, which has been entirely due to the littany of poor decisions culminating in the current debt. The notion that GP is toxic and the cause is completely illogical. GP afforded the club the opportunity to save a fortune and still be fully compliant with the Taylor report and yield 40k at the beginning of the all seater era. It's not GP's fault that they did the absolute bare minimum.
BMD can and should be able to sell its qualities and benefits without the need to scapegoat our ancestral home that had been neglected and allowed to be left behind.
Feel free to demonstrate how our current potentially highly toxic debt is the fault of GP, (that has practically had the squate root of nothing spent on it in 30+yrs), and nothing to do with a new stadium that failed to raise any funding from any major financial institution, even despite an owner funding most of it.
I'd say that witnessing easily the highest number of seasons in the top flight is a very high bar actually, and certainly not indicative of toxicity.