New Crest Consultation

[davek]

Speechless. I thought they'd put a lot of effort into it...

No mate. They just crowd sourced and pulled out three mediocre efforts.

Probably cost the club about 50K or some such ridiculous amount.

 

[Toffe3m4n]

Are these seriously the best 3 designs the club came up with?!

I give up....

 

[meagher94]

"OMG this seasons crest is better than those!"

No. It really, really isn't.

 

[fozzy]

what the fook happend to all the fan designs ffs?

 

[Blue Truth]

The first one is the only half decent one but even then it's not great

 

[Brennan]

Think people are really overreacting here.

The first one is nice in my opinion. A simplified version of the old crest which is fine by me. Don't mind the third one, but would definitely pick the first one.

All three designs are better than the current terrible design IMO.

Of course they are, any reason to moan.

People saying all three are worse than the current one are just being contrary. The left option is most similar to our old badge and is a vast improvement over the current with it's lack of NSNO and laurels.

The second one is similar to the current and is gash, the NSNO placement just looks weird.

The third one is okay, a definite improvement over the current.

 

[AaronTheBlue]

All of them are proper, proper terrible.

 

[Huyton Layne]

As someone else said it's indeed a case of picking the least worst. I'd go with number 1. 2 is gashness and 3 is in between.

 

[SteKelly]

2nd one easy.

 

[Goat]

1 is almost the same as the old 1, just fatter and crapper.

Sweet baby Jesus.

Number 1, but all 3 are not great.

 

[Alio]

First one.

 

[davek]

2 and 3 are complete muck. Who in their right mind would pick those two for consideration after the last fiasco?

Unbelievable.

 

[icburns]

*sigh

not great, but better than what they first gave us. I like the tower, actually.

 

[BoysInBlue]

First one by a country mile.

2nd one is just a revamped version of the current mess of a badge.

3rd one is just weird. Not getting anyone's love for that. It's a shield within a shield? What's that weird gap at the bottom between the two? Looks a mess.

Thought they would have been better than that. MilkyOneCreative's designs were better.

Important thing now is to make sure 1 gets the vote. Would hate to be stuck with the other two.

 

[Mrk]

No mate. They just crowd sourced and pulled out three mediocre efforts.

Probably cost the club about 50K or some such ridiculous amount.

Even mediocre is generous. Ok, they've tried to do it in as short amount of time as possible, that's understandable, but it just looks like they've just chucked everything into a badge without thinking about the most important thing, the design.

Disappointed.