2025/26 Michael Vincent Keane

[banno]

And red cards deservedly happen. Game's changed, for better or worse. You can't act like that.

They put up the rule on TV and even the middle aged Neville said it was negligent and should have been a yellow at most

 

[Hinchcliffe's Corner]

They put up the rule on TV and even the middle aged Neville said it was negligent and should have been a yellow at most

Gary Neville

 

[GoldenToffee]

Sell Gueye in January after that. Embarrassing and completely unacceptable. Send a point that Everton FC does not tolerate players attacking each other.

 

[gianthogweed]

Keane was a sleep the slap woke him up

 

[matty1878]

Sell Gueye in January after that. Embarrassing and completely unacceptable. Send a point that Everton FC does not tolerate players attacking each other.

don’t be stupid mate

 

[blulouie]

Sell Gueye in January after that. Embarrassing and completely unacceptable. Send a point that Everton FC does not tolerate players attacking each other.

Is this for real ????

 

[kiss the crest]

Sell Gueye in January after that. Embarrassing and completely unacceptable. Send a point that Everton FC does not tolerate players attacking each other.

Can't agree with this, Gana is a winner and he does not want players standing around letting other players have free shots.
Plus he is our best midfielder

 

[banno]

Gary Neville

He read the ruling as did the main commentator. Yellow at most

 

[Pettifogger]

Sell Gueye in January after that. Embarrassing and completely unacceptable. Send a point that Everton FC does not tolerate players attacking each other.

Gana is probably one of the most hardworking and buttoned up players in EFC's modern era

Perhaps we should give him a chance to sort it out and take accountability first

 

[preposterousvelios]

Nonsense..... Gana 100% at fault

I'm not saying Gana’s not at fault. Just don't understand the pearl clutching over suggestions that Keane also is.

He clearly pushes Gana first, and was responsible for us almost conceding immediately before which is the cause of the fight.

It shouldn't matter as it should never be a sending off. Daft headloss but the ref doesn't need to potentially throw the game in the first 20 minutes for that.

 

[Osamabindiesel]

Took the slap like a champ

 

[Miked1e]

Is this for real ????

Yes it is for real…. Regardless of the player and or how bad the action it’s embarrassing as a club. Get shut now

Potentially cost us the match for being a d*ck

 

[Efcjake]

Anyone blaming him for Gana losing their heads is blindly holding Keane's many other trespasses against him.

All Gana had to do was clear it and not play a blind ball across the box to nobody and when he was called out on it he lost the plot.

 

[MaximusEvertonius]

Absolute great tackle again, Keane. Well done, lad.

 

[preposterousvelios]

Comfortably bee our best cb this season.

Definitely had a brain fart before the sending off. But gana getting in his face was rediculous. Gana was completely the aggressor in the incident and a absolute idiot for throwing a slap.

Keane is literally telling gana to calm down and gana puts his face into keane's so he pushes him away.

You obviously dont like keane tbh im not his biggest fan but lets not make stuff up

To me it looked like Keane was trying to calm it down, absurd to blame him for that

This thread honestly makes me feel like I'm going mad.

Watched it back 4 or 5 times and clearly it's Keane who squares up initially, and it's Keane who pushes Gana first. Gana is an idiot to react how he has and is equally responsible, but I don't know why people are trying to only blame Gana.


People act like Keane gets blamed for everything, to me this season it feels more like a lot of people on this forum are willing to perform intense mental gymnastics to avoid blaming him for anything.