2018/19 Michael Keane

[COYBL25]

Best of the 3 I would say but I think we need to spend big on a partner for him. Mina has yet to convince and Zouma will be too expensive and not quite good enough.

You could have the best centre half in the world playing alongside Keane and he`d spend half of the game bailing the donkey out.

 

[toffeeblue9]

Didn't think he deserved to start the game after costing us the last league game

He did some good stuff, but his use of the ball was really erratic and he almost gifted them a goal

Did well in the air, can't deny that

He has certainly improver this season but of late I think he's regressed - December to today was a bad period for us but I think he possibly has had the worst of everyone

Currently he would be my 3rd choice of the three centre backs, with Zouma in 1st.

 

[NilSatisOptimum]

I must be watching a different player to some of you.

The block at the end was great, but he's an accident waiting to happen on the ball, and a sitting duck again pace. I'd be looking to find a partner for Zouma in the summer.

He has got to get rid of those mistakes, just can't be having them. It's like he is slipping into another dimension when they happen because there is literally no reason for them sometimes.

 

[SupaStake]

He plays some fantastic passes, does look a bit nervous sometimes

 

[Bluerover]

Brilliant tackle on 91.06. Gosling could have equalized. Fair dues for that Michael.

 

[billyblue80]

The new Jags ha ha, good on the ball, pretty good defender with some massive ricks in his locker.

 

[Neiler]

Great today.

Again.

 

[Eggsyblueskin]

He’s a much improved player on last season , let’s face it that wasn’t hard, but I’m still not convinced . He’s competent but those unnecessary mistakes concern me could have cost us the game today, plus he’s slow and doesn’t score enough (unlucky with that header today though.
Zouma is the better player for me. Mina needs time to settle , so it’s Keane for now.

 

[TheGeeseofGoodisonRoad]

two big defensive errors in consecutive league games but if he can cut those out he's our best center back for me, fantastic goal saving tackle. great to see a player push past a bad season like that

 

[fandjango]

If the first half of that is Moyes, you're bonkers, sir.

Rescued us from oblivion.

Errr
Marcel Marco

 

[Toffeelover]

Don't think he really settles to Silva's 3 CB tactic.

 

[COYBL25]

He`s immobile, gets caught out of position all the time and generally unbalances and constantly unsettles the defence.

He reminds me of a gash Mark Higgins.

 

[smileychap]

Errr
Marcel Marco

I apologise, sir

I thought it was Moyes Martinez. I loathe the stick Moyes gets, loved the values that era was built upon and the progress that came out of it. Would love a few of those home grown guys that give 110% every game. We have talent in this squad, just think we'd be more Everton with a few of our own youth in there. Hopefully Marcel is the man for that, even if Marco isn't (though they probably deserve a coupla more seasons and windows together).

 

[fandjango]

I apologise, sir

I thought it was Moyes Martinez. I loathe the stick Moyes gets, loved the values that era was built upon and the progress that came out of it. Would love a few of those home grown guys that give 110% every game. We have talent in this squad, just think we'd be more Everton with a few of our own youth in there. Hopefully Marcel is the man for that, even if Marco isn't (though they probably deserve a coupla more seasons and windows together).

I totally agree with you

 

[Nymzee]

Scares me less than the other two which I never thought I’d say.