Transfer Rumour Memphis Depay

Zatara · December 4, 2016

Dylan said:
I am not joining in and picking a side, here, but I think he was referencing the United supporters who were all too happy to get shut of Mata over the break, and now he is rejuvenated under Mourinho.

Therefore, United fans know shazbat about footy, therefore shouldn't be relied on as an authority as to whether Depay is any good or not.

I want him to join solely because his name is 'Memphis'.

That + Mourinho sold him to United in the first place as well of course as offloading others like De Bruyne.

BlueToff · December 4, 2016

MoutsGoat said:
Juan Mata, a player given his debut by Ronald Koeman.

Who then went on to win Valencia the last trophy they won.

In 2007.

lollollollol

'a one man mission', deliberately trying to sabotage his career I guess

Dymak · December 4, 2016

Mikey_Fitzgerald said:
To be fair, Dymak hates everyone

I don't think you could evidence that. I may be critical but I don't hate anyone. I'm not alone in being critical either, there is plenty to be critical about.

d4kyxx · December 4, 2016

If he isn't good enough for them he's not good enough for us. We never learn

BlueToff · December 4, 2016

d4kyxx said:
If he isn't good enough for them he's not good enough for us. We never learn

Man Utd have a better squad than Everton.

d4kyxx · December 4, 2016

BlueToff said:
Man Utd have a better squad than Everton.

Do they?

Have you watched Depay play for them? He looks woefully out of place in this league and I very much doubt he will improve on what we have bar pace

mixed_up · December 4, 2016

d4kyxx said:
If he isn't good enough for them he's not good enough for us. We never learn

Steven Pienaar was not good enough for Dortmund but was brilliant for us in spells. Just cos Depay has struggled to fit into one Premier League club doesn't mean he'd struggle at Goodison.

BlueToff · December 4, 2016

d4kyxx said:
Do they?

Have you watched Depay play for them? He looks woefully out of place in this league and I very much doubt he will improve on what we have bar pace

Yes, they do.

And yes, I have.

I'm not convinced on his aptitude either, but the lad has an abundance of talent. If Koeman wants him and reckons he can get the best out of him then he'd be a huge improvement for that left side, considering we have four right wingers (the best of which will be off to ACON for a month in January)

bicycleheader · December 4, 2016

Dymak said:
I don't think you could evidence that. I may be critical but I don't hate anyone. I'm not alone in being critical either, there is plenty to be critical about.

i dont think ive seen you post anything positive in the 3yrs ive been on this forum.

i had also assumed using the above evidence that you hate everything and everyone

d4kyxx · December 4, 2016

mixed_up said:
Steven Pienaar was not good enough for Dortmund but was brilliant for us in spells. Just cos Depay has struggled to fit into one Premier League club doesn't mean he'd struggle at Goodison.

It's possible of course but unlikely.

Dymak · December 4, 2016

bicycleheader said:
i dont think ive seen you post anything positive in the 3yrs ive been on this forum.

i had also assumed using the above evidence that you hate everything and everyone

That's nonsense tbh. Maybe you could refer to all the positive things that I have been negative towards? If I've been doing it non-stop for three years then there should be a massive list of them? I welcomed Moshiri, certainly more than those yanks that everyone was about to bend over for, and I welcome the news that a large part of our debt has been settled. Your list will probably involve me disagreeing about how good the likes of McCarthy and Martinez are!

Mikey_Fitzgerald · December 4, 2016

Dymak said:
I don't think you could evidence that. I may be critical but I don't hate anyone. I'm not alone in being critical either, there is plenty to be critical about.

You are sustained by hate and motivated by misery mate

Embrace it. Own it

ilikecheese · December 4, 2016

Is he ours yet?

ijjysmith · December 4, 2016

d4kyxx · December 4, 2016

BlueToff said:
Yes, they do.

And yes, I have.

I'm not convinced on his aptitude either, but the lad has an abundance of talent. If Koeman wants him and reckons he can get the best out of him then he'd be a huge improvement for that left side, considering we have four right wingers (the best of which will be off to ACON for a month in January)

Some players ie depay star in leagues of lower quality at a younger age but can't make the step up to tougher leagues. That's not to say he won't still improve as he is still young but I'm not sure he is capable of being someone who will help us make the top four