Marcelo Bielsa or Sean Dyche?

[kiss the crest]

Last time these to faced each other, before both were sacked

Burnley 1 - 1 Leeds
Leeds 3 - 1 Burnley

Dyche won 3/30
Bielsa won 6/30
Before they were both sacked

 

[Drico]

In a crisis: pragmatist over idealist every time.

If this was the summer and we were safe my choice would have been Bielsa.

I agree completely.

I think both have their attributes. I tend towards pragmatism over vision in a crisis where time is of the essence and precludes the realising of any vision.

But it won't matter unless we can buy some serious goal power in the next week.

 

[Drico]

I went for Dyche on the basis the squad doesn't change this window.

Bielsa would run this current crop into the ground. The cloob would bankrupt themselves spending any potential transfer money on 22 portable defibrillators.

Bielsa would be my choice if we managed to buy players suited to his demands.

At this point, I feel like any manager coming in is walking the green mile. Sad times to support this cloob.

Honestly, "if the squad doesn't change", it doesn't matter who comes in. There are no goals in this squad. It HAS to change.

 

[Drico]

Last time these to faced each other, before both were sacked

Burnley 1 - 1 Leeds

So, you're saying they didn't lose?

 

[Pabbers]

Whoever it is now, we all just need to get behind them.

We needs to be realistic about the position we are in.

 

[Terrarian]

Aids or syphilis tough choice

I have no clue, they're contrasting styles, neither win anything, who do we have the players best suited too? arew we looking long term or stop gap? I don't hate Dyche, have to remember the size of club Burnley are and the size of their budget.

Seems both have pros and cons, we are in such a mess, it's hard to know who will do better, truth is until in the hotseat we will never know.

I kinda want to see the players beasted by murderball but not at the cost of relegation.

 

[kiss the crest]

So, you're saying they didn't lose?

Just edited it

 

[Harryflashman]

Where's the 'I don't pretend to know" option?

Of all the polls I’ve ever seen I’ve never voted cheese on toast and the first time I need that option it’s not here

 

[Peter The Dog]

unfortunately, both aren't fit for purpose at this moment in time.

 

[MACCA75]

Bielsa. Because I don’t want to see us play at that testimonial pace we played at v West Ham. Neither will keep us up unless we sign 2 decent forward players anyway.

 

[davek]

I agree completely.

I think both have their attributes. I tend towards pragmatism over vision in a crisis where time is of the essence and precludes the realising of any vision.

But it won't matter unless we can buy some serious goal power in the next week.

That's my concern.

This managerial appointment should be on the back-burner in favour of signing players.

 

[trueblue84]

Last time these to faced each other, before both were sacked

Burnley 1 - 1 Leeds
Leeds 3 - 1 Burnley

Dyche won 3/30
Bielsa won 6/30
Before they were both sacked

So lampard then?

 

[ToffeeScot]

It's a rough choice. I think Dyche probably gives us the best chance of staying up but also I think he's a terrible long term appointment. Bielsa would weed out a lot of the useless rot at the club but I think we would probably go down with him. On that basis you'd argue Dyche but I really worry about the players we will end up buying with him and I wish we could progress and play exciting stuff for once.

 

[Wat Tyler]

Both take us down. The board have killed us.

 

[Moomin]

Team El Loco 4 life