Yes but it cost us the game and that's what matters. Yes players make mistakes, Distin in the semi final did and plenty of other times our players have made mistakes. But to make it in the 96th minute of a game at Anfield when it's 0-0, is just unforgivable. I don't care if it's kneejerk, or not I'd quite happily sell him in January. It just means we have to go yet another season, unless we draw them in the cup, with an awful defeat at Anfield. All players make mistakes, but very rarely at times, when they matter so much. It means that thousands of blues, we have an awful night and a appalling week of abuse from their RS colleagues and people at school. People have already said on here, they have got into arguments with their spouses, losing is bad enough but to lose in that way, is just too hard to deal with. I'd be quite happy to never see him in an Everton shirt again, he also has kept them in the title race.