- Status
Tony’s Carp
Player Valuation: £40m
I'm not sure he has the potential and the technical ability to become a regular PL starter in the near future, but in a way that would make me more inclined to keep him for the squad this season rather than loan him out. If he'd had a really successful loan at Derby the next step would be a championship club to keep that development trajectory going but I'm not sure he gets starts at a decent championship club and a second league one loan isn't a forward step.
So if he's sort of between two stools I'd maybe just hold onto him for a bench option- if Gray goes we are lacking in real pace and Dobbin is a guy who could cause problems late in games off the bench, and with the 5 sub rule that's a good option to have. And you never know if playing and training at a higher level things might click technically.
Eggsyblueskin
Player Valuation: £40m
He was the only footballer on the field today.
Branthwaite and Onana did reasonably well.
But ,apart from Pickford, the rest can be rendered down for dog food,
Branthwaite and Onana did reasonably well.
But ,apart from Pickford, the rest can be rendered down for dog food,
Quite frustrating to watch really. He clearly has a lot of ability, and does a lot of good things. but it seems that the one big weakness in his game is shooting and finishing. Not ideal in a team who can't score goals.
Blast_of_Cannock
Player Valuation: £8m
Doesn't look ready for the Prem yet. But neither did Gordon when he came back from Preston. Hopefully we can rinse Newcastle out of another £40mil in 18 months...
Still better than Maupay tho.
Still better than Maupay tho.
I thought he did when he came on but he is a winger, not a striker imo.
He stretches teams with his pace and got a couple of good crosses in, but is not a good finisher.
However with experience his finishing will improve,
He stretches teams with his pace and got a couple of good crosses in, but is not a good finisher.
However with experience his finishing will improve,
BullensRoad
Player Valuation: £20m
No one knows. Gordon was shipped out and didn't impress but ended up selling him for a large sum.
I think he's got more of an end product but would prepare he goes out on loan for another year.
I think he's got more of an end product but would prepare he goes out on loan for another year.
Spadge Vernacular
Player Valuation: £60m
Typical that we get a prospect but the Fifa-arty cannot wait to run the kid out of town. Shame on you.
Osamabindiesel
Player Valuation: £60m
He is the one guy that seems to know how to make decent runs. Just having somebody to stretch the field would make a huge difference. I’m not going to advocate keeping him or sending him out on loan (because I don’t know what our transfer strategy is or our strategy in general), but in a situation like ours where we have no talent, these are the guys you need to integrate into the rotation and prop them up to sell or give them real league experience. We can’t keep being cowards with our lineups.
Rooney_Tunes
Player Valuation: £40m
I would keep him and play him from the bench regularly...
He knows how to make those runs, he's quick, he scores one, and some confidence seeps in he could be a viable option, especially off the bench.
Unfortunately, it's a chance we have to take, not because of his exceptional skill level, but because of the dearth of the squad's skill level in the striking department.
….he’s not been sent on loan yet which is a sign Dyche might want to use him. He might give him something different with that pace, especially on the counter.
Paul Rideout
Player Valuation: £35m
He was the only forward player in that game that looked like he could get a chance frm nothing.
I’d keep him and work on him, solid bench option
I’d keep him and work on him, solid bench option
- Status
