thirdmantackle
Player Valuation: £35m
Look what that buffoon from the RS did in a CL final.
Pickford is liable to do that in any game now
Pickford is liable to do that in any game now
- Status
Carloblues
Player Valuation: £30m
No excuses anymore, even the beat keepers go through spells but his form over say the past 20 games has been the worst form of any keeper I can ever remember, literally on average a bad mistake per game.
We're not even talking like oh he should have saved it mistakes were talking worst mistakes imaginable every game
We're not even talking like oh he should have saved it mistakes were talking worst mistakes imaginable every game
Davideeyore
Player Valuation: £20m
We need a couple of goals to counter balance the goal we concede via Pickford. It's tough but we're rising to it
ButOkayThatsFootball
Player Valuation: £750k
Question is for how long do you allow that phase to continue before you make the decision that his presence is having an actively detrimental effect on the team?
I also think he's a talent, in his first season he clearly showed that. But when he's made 9 errors leading to goals (more than any other keeper) since the start of last season, you've got to start questioning whether our priorities must shift to brining in an alternative to give him a spell out of the team (both for his own good and for the good of the team).
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
That balls up today: it's roots are in all of his errors - he is in two minds at what he should do. Today, he had in mind either catch the ball or pat the ball down and then gather it. In the end he did neither.
At other times it's whether to put the ball out or catch it.
There is a fatal error in this lad because his judgement on these things is confused right at the moment he should have opted for one option and stuck to it.
It's why he's decent at reactive saves: no time to think and judge what's best.
Itls what his antics do to a defence as much as his own howlers that are an outrage.
I just dont get 3 managers keeping faith with this unstable character.
As well as Ancelotti has done, keeping Pickford as his number 1 GK is a huge black mark on his Everton resume.
He'll cost us. He;s cost us in the past but it's usually the difference between 7th or 8th and midtable or below; this time it'll be the difference between 7th or 8th and the CL/EL places.
What is this club doing employing a confirmed failure in our goal?
At other times it's whether to put the ball out or catch it.
There is a fatal error in this lad because his judgement on these things is confused right at the moment he should have opted for one option and stuck to it.
It's why he's decent at reactive saves: no time to think and judge what's best.
Itls what his antics do to a defence as much as his own howlers that are an outrage.
I just dont get 3 managers keeping faith with this unstable character.
As well as Ancelotti has done, keeping Pickford as his number 1 GK is a huge black mark on his Everton resume.
He'll cost us. He;s cost us in the past but it's usually the difference between 7th or 8th and midtable or below; this time it'll be the difference between 7th or 8th and the CL/EL places.
What is this club doing employing a confirmed failure in our goal?
Big Sams Undies
Player Valuation: £15m
Can we please stop using the word "phase" as if he's only been crap for a month or so please? 
He is gonna cost us the title
peteblue
Welcome back Wayne
I’ve said it for ages. He simply cannot catch and hold a ball. Surely we have someone who can teach him this, or get him some sticky gloves ffs. He will bring tears to the team and fans if he keeps this up......
Rudolf Hucker
Player Valuation: £30m
Robles was a considerably better keeper than Pickford.
Pickford is a shot stopper. That's it. He's usually very good with reaction saves.
Pickford is a shot stopper. That's it. He's usually very good with reaction saves.
Terrarian
Player Valuation: £50m
I'll go balls deep and say Stek didn't make as many errors as JP currently, he's lucky we are scoring goals but it'll be a matter of time before it costs us, it'll be an important game as well.
Toast
Player Valuation: £80m
I never have if I’m honest.
windymiller
Player Valuation: £50m
He reminds me of David James to be honest, like a shrunken version. Terrible on crosses, loses his concentration all of the time, inexplicably selected for England etc...
carolinablue232
Player Valuation: £70m
2 year “phase“ now royds. What about him screams talent? I don’t see him as quality in any area id expect from a keeper. Genuinely none of them.
- Status
