James McCarthy

[ilikecheese]

IF we sign a some of the names we're after, cash in on this one ASAP. Despite his limitations, he was brilliant in his first season, and was a integral cog to why we were so good defensively. He's been off the boil for two seasons now partially down to injury, and partially down to overall fitness IMO.

 

[steele]

As Gueye is in, what will happen with McCarthy? Can we get 15 mill or should he stay and fight?

 

[kithnou]

As Gueye is in, what will happen with McCarthy? Can we get 15 mill or should he stay and fight?

Get rid for any amount to any club willing...

 

[ToffeeTim]

Sell

 

[Joey66]

Have we sold him yet looking for a scout from an opposing club who has been on the ale all day!

 

[Darren Higgs]

Swansea lost out to stoke for allen. Maybe we should offer mccarthy for williams.

 

[Joey66]

Swansea lost out to stoke for allen. Maybe we should offer mccarthy for williams.

Thier not that daft!

 

[jh18]

As Gueye is in, what will happen with McCarthy? Can we get 15 mill or should he stay and fight?

Only sell if we can get a better replacement like a Witsel. We lack strength of depth of squad, so it'd be pointless just selling him for the money.

 

[Efcjake]

As Gueye is in, what will happen with McCarthy? Can we get 15 mill or should he stay and fight?

Think he will be sold for a bit more than that.

 

[carolinablue232]

Assuming we sign either Witsel or Carvalho to an already crowded midfield, he has to be one shifted out. Step forward David Moyes, and claim thine prize.

 

[diggerdestroyer]

Still reckon he has evertrying to play just in front of back 4. Covers ground can tackle and a simple pass. What more does one want.not a box to box player.

 

[KaiserEFC]

Replace him with someone creative please Everton

Thaaaaaaaanks

 

[stamullenblue]

Still a good player for me. Used badly by brown shoes but never stops running and trying - needs to get forward more and become the box to box player we need .. Hope he doesn't go !

 

[bluelord49]

Get rid.....sorry but just not good enough.

 

[Pittsburgh Footy]

Not ready to sell him off - yet. I want to see what a few months with Koeman can do.

He looked a completely different player against Norwich. Sure, neither team had anything to play for, but he appeared free from the tactical shackles that everyone on the squad was tied to during the last 4 months under Bobby.

At the very least, he's a good back up for Gana. We need a decent sized squad to compete week in week out.

He stays for me.