James McCarthy

[thebluefox]

Did you think he was crap too mate?

no mate , i thought
goat was though

 

[Goat]

I just wish I'd studied him on MOTD and live games before so I knew how ace he was mate.

The lid is literally perfect for us. He's Everton if I've ever seen a player like that.

I thought he was a 5/10 kinda player, worth a punt on the off chance he could improve to a 6/10, no more than 5m tho.

After watching him, hes a 8/10 standard, prone to 9.5/10 on the regs, if I could design my perfect Everton player, he would be James McCarthy.

no mate , i thought
goat was though

You told me he was rubbish lad.

 

[Goat]

Hes everything Moutinho could have been.

 

[chicoazul]

no mate , i thought
goat was though

Hahaha I would expect no less from Billy Bunter himself mate.

 

[Baines' left foot]

Love him already.

 

[thebluefox]

I thought he was a 5/10 kinda player, worth a punt on the off chance he could improve to a 6/10, no more than 5m tho.

After watching him, hes a 8/10 standard, prone to 9.5/10 on the regs, if I could design my perfect Everton player, he would be James McCarthy.



You told me he was rubbish lad.

ha, 2 year ago i told ye we had to sign him , 13 mill will turn out to be a steal

 

[TraffordBlue]

Can't decide whether I prefer McCarthy or Barry. Either way they're both quality additions to the team. If Gibbo was fit more regularly it would be hard to pick the favoured 2 out of the 3.

 

[Big Fat Sam]

Him and Barry were both excellent yesterday, albeit against poor opposition. Let's see how they do against Fellaini and Carrick on Wednesday...

 

[Sozzled]

I thought he was a 5/10 kinda player, worth a punt on the off chance he could improve to a 6/10, no more than 5m tho.

After watching him, hes a 8/10 standard, prone to 9.5/10 on the regs, if I could design my perfect Everton player, he would be James McCarthy.

Mine would be Barkley, hands down.

 

[bluemangroup]

Can't decide whether I prefer McCarthy or Barry. Either way they're both quality additions to the team. If Gibbo was fit more regularly it would be hard to pick the favoured 2 out of the 3.

Gibson and McCarthy all day longggg for me.

 

[AaronTheBlue]

Awaits the Irish posters going mental

Part irish myself so i couldn't really care

 

[Great Dane]

He will be captain within 2 seasons I think and be so highly rated that he will constantly be lazy-journos-linked with bigger clubs.

 

[Christiffa25]

Mine would be Barkley, hands down.

Yep this 100%. Or maybe Rooney until he cheated on us!

McCarthy is ace tho!

 

[jackyboy]

Gareth Barry just edges him in the fave player stakes at the minute.

 

[Housequake]

Gareth Barry just edges him in the fave player stakes at the minute.

Him flipping on the Liverpool physio was fantastic, captain behaviour that.