James McCarthy

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tubey said:
Apart from the fact that Fellaini was far from ****e for the first 18 months he was here, but whatever. Young Player of the Year for his debut season etc.
Click to expand...

says you in your opinion...but who made you the oracle of football? I watched him be a dog for at least 18 months and i genuinely dont give a 5hit if he got young player of the year by some sort of default.

My point was, 18 months is long enough for fans to have strong opinions about. I wouldnt have wasted my time or been concerned in anyway by what you seen from a debut with 20 minutes to go in one of the most frantic games we will see this season at GP. Man U and the derby will probably only be more hectic than that.

Youve tried to look like a football guru highlighting 'concerns' to raise your footballing opinion above others on here when realy all thats happened is people think your a clown for even worrying about what the kid done or didnt do in 20 minutes.

Dont know if you play football, or did do and to what level, but surely you see how hard that game must have been to come on and make a debut in? 20 minutes coming on into that? Like i said previously...he done well not to be shat out because Chelsea threw everything at us, but whatever, you be concerned that he didnt come on and take complete control of the game.
 
andybaker said:
says you in your opinion...but who made you the oracle of football? I watched him be a dog for at least 18 months and i genuinely dont give a 5hit if he got young player of the year by some sort of default.

My point was, 18 months is long enough for fans to have strong opinions about. I wouldnt have wasted my time or been concerned in anyway by what you seen from a debut with 20 minutes to go in one of the most frantic games we will see this season at GP. Man U and the derby will probably only be more hectic than that.

Youve tried to look like a football guru highlighting 'concerns' to raise your footballing opinion above others on here when realy all thats happened is people think your a clown for even worrying about what the kid done or didnt do in 20 minutes.

Dont know if you play football, or did do and to what level, but surely you see how hard that game must have been to come on and make a debut in? 20 minutes coming on into that? Like i said previously...he done well not to be shat out because Chelsea threw everything at us, but whatever, you be concerned that he didnt come on and take complete control of the game.
Click to expand...

well said
 

blueblue said:
It really is a big problem for Martinez in midfield. a good problem.

If Barry continues in anything like the form he showed last Saturday then he has to play every week.
McCarthy is a player we all know Martinez admires and the fact that he spent 13m of money we can't afford will tell you of the regard he has for the player and intends to play him each week.
In preseason Gibson was the main fulcrum around which our midfield revolved,Martinez spoke about what a good player he is.
As with Moyes,I think Osman will find his way into the team most weeks under RM,a player underrated by supporters but appreciated by professionals.

So, off you go RM,sort that out no pressure.
Click to expand...

It´s that squad concept that are doing our heads in isn´t it? The fact that not all our good players have to start week in week out.

My point is I can see Gibson, McCarthy, Barry, Osman and Barkley rotated as injuries, fatigue and suspensions take their toll.
 
andybaker said:
says you in your opinion...but who made you the oracle of football? I watched him be a dog for at least 18 months and i genuinely dont give a 5hit if he got young player of the year by some sort of default.

My point was, 18 months is long enough for fans to have strong opinions about. I wouldnt have wasted my time or been concerned in anyway by what you seen from a debut with 20 minutes to go in one of the most frantic games we will see this season at GP. Man U and the derby will probably only be more hectic than that.

Youve tried to look like a football guru highlighting 'concerns' to raise your footballing opinion above others on here when realy all thats happened is people think your a clown for even worrying about what the kid done or didnt do in 20 minutes.

Dont know if you play football, or did do and to what level, but surely you see how hard that game must have been to come on and make a debut in? 20 minutes coming on into that? Like i said previously...he done well not to be shat out because Chelsea threw everything at us, but whatever, you be concerned that he didnt come on and take complete control of the game.
Click to expand...

Right, so in the blue bit, you're criticising my stance on Fellaini, which is backed up by a professional award for his performances, and making out like I'm being ludicrous by pointing that out.

Then, in the red bit, you're discounting a professional award and saying your opinion means more than it - that you "don't give a sh1t" apparently. That in fact your opinion means more than David Moyes and the footballing world at large given that the manager heralded him as good as "anyone in the league" exactly 16 months after months of stunning football in 2009/10 and was linked with a big money move to Chelsea and Man Utd in the January 2010 transfer window.

And you have the gall to say I think I'm the oracle of football?! :lol:

Here's where you're a fool - you claim that 18 months is enough time to have a (wrong) opinion on a player. I've had four years to form an opinion on McCarthy and, guess what, you clown (your word, not mine), it's a positive opinion - but hey, that doesn't fit your agenda does it? It suits you more to make up this mythical stance that I've "judged" the kid off the back of 20 minutes because you're dying, absolutely dying to have a pop at me and you just can't get the foothold you need to do so.

You're another one who can join the "get lost" pile.
 

chicoazul said:
Tubes likes to be contrary, its his way of being uber cool on the internet. Not too dissimilar to me lying about all the boss place I've meant to have lived. Everyone got to have a backstory yo.
Click to expand...

He's got an Ignore sheet longer than Pancakes tick list after this
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top