Christ your memory is chilling, there's some nightmarish names on that list Dave.
James McCarthy
- Thread starter GrandOldTeam
- Start date
- Status
Christ your memory is chilling, there's some nightmarish names on that list Dave.
jerseytoffee
Player Valuation: £10m
Heitinga won our player of the year didn’t he one season?
Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
We’ll have to agree to disagree. Even in that list of ‘utter tripe’ though you have an Everton captain who we bought for 3 million and gave us 7 years service, a striker picked up for free that we sold for 10 million and was rated by Martinez also, and a World Cup finalist centreback who managed to split up Jags and Distin (both oddly missing off your list of good signings along with Coleman the 60k kid who is now captain after a decade) and was player of the season.
A lot of the rest of it is full of loan players, kids, and back up goalkeepers the type of signings you have to make when you have barely any budget but your first 11 is decent. Any manager of any team outside of the chequebook teams probably has a similar list of players.
But on McCarthy....he’s not as good as Gueye, and I don’t think Gueye is the level we require either, that’s unfortunately the standard we now have to find if we want to get to the top.
Paul Rideout
Player Valuation: £40m
Fair on the Rooney.
I personally believe Coleman to be a better signing due to low outlay, captain, loyal to the club.
I’d possibly put stones above Lukaku because it was a low outlay, and pretty sure the price we received was a greater multiple than that of Lukaku.
From a goals and profit perspective Lukaku was the best no doubt, but the hassle and disrespect, plus the higher outlay for his purchase... I’d not say he was the best.
Depends on how you define ‘best’
BornBlue76
Player Valuation: £35m
Where is that God of a striker Yakubu!
evertonarntwe
Player Valuation: £35m
Heitinga definitely wasnt bang average. Didnt he win player of the season once as well? Liked him me
everton1953
Player Valuation: £40m
Getting back to the main subject is the rumour about McCarthy just that, media rubbish or can we wish him well at Palace? Mick McCarthy will be delighted and will pick him immediately.
bluebud
Player Valuation: £35m
You missed Yobo out, he was a good signing gave us some pace at the back, we’d of got our money back if the Turks had paid up. Marcus Bent was cheap did a job and got sold for profit. Yak slotted for us, Neill, Beckford and Naismith all made us a decent profit so we’re decent signings, a few others without being fantastic we’re budget fillers that did ok.
Some decent loans as well Donovan, Manny Fernandes, Jo.
Thomasc
Formerly known as By God I'm Blue
Yep just think of the damage Martinez could have done of given longer! In only 3 seasons he gave us
Alcaraz
Atsu
Rodriguez
McGeady
Niasse
Tarashaj
Stanek
Henen
Kone
Eto (who sussed out he had signed for a clown very quickly)
Cleverly (who he called one of the best midfielders in England )lol
Galloway
Besic
Byrne
See we can all do this
Martinez best signings were clearly Barry, McCarthy (first season) and Lukaku, though Lukaku had his best season under Koeman.
Now there’s your actual reality.
You won’t respond to this I expect as it smashes your posts into tiny little pieces.
Sky isnt the greatest source, but got a feeling theres something in this.
B
Big Fat Sam
Guest
Ignoring money, it simply has to be Cahill.
Funny how time changes people's perspective
Players like Jermaine Beckford getting slagged off for being average back in a period of the club's history when we didn't have two pennies to rub together
Yet here we are, all monied up in 2019 - and Jermaine Beckford scored more goals in his one full season than any of our strikers did last year
Wonder which position needs some attention?
Players like Jermaine Beckford getting slagged off for being average back in a period of the club's history when we didn't have two pennies to rub together
Yet here we are, all monied up in 2019 - and Jermaine Beckford scored more goals in his one full season than any of our strikers did last year
Wonder which position needs some attention?
Be sad to see Jamsey go, hes a very good player.
Its a massive shame his injuries have limited his contribution, but we are not innocent on that score either. When you weigh it up a fresh start might be best for both parties, but 8 mill seems low, id sell or 10-12, that said it almost all profit and he would be on a decent bit of wedge in wage.
Its a massive shame his injuries have limited his contribution, but we are not innocent on that score either. When you weigh it up a fresh start might be best for both parties, but 8 mill seems low, id sell or 10-12, that said it almost all profit and he would be on a decent bit of wedge in wage.
Thomasc
Formerly known as By God I'm Blue
[
You take what offer is on the table IMO, any return now on a player who has played as little as he has is a good offer.
You take what offer is on the table IMO, any return now on a player who has played as little as he has is a good offer.
Remember, he hates Baines, and Jags
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
