James McCarthy

[Zatara]

Cant see why we would start him?

We start him = he gets injured = we cant sell him.

 

[Jonte]

The Fail reporting an interest in ‘out-of-favour’ James McCarthy by West Ham on loan.

 

[Groucho]

There’s rumours he’s playing on Saturday.

With him being willing to do the side’s dirty work, he may just be the answer to Silva’s preferred 4-3-3 (where Morgan Schneiderlin is too lazy).

Ok not a long term fix but he could fill that “number 6” roll that Silva’s said his system required but we missed out on in summer.

 

[Billysgingham.]

There’s rumours he’s playing on Saturday.

With him being willing to do the side’s dirty work, he may just be the answer to Silva’s preferred 4-3-3 (where Morgan Schneiderlin is too lazy).

Ok not a long term fix but he could fill that “number 6” roll that Silva’s said his system required but we missed out on in summer.

Let's hope he doesn't get injured and plays well so we can off load the waster.

 

[Groucho]

Let's hope he doesn't get injured and plays well so we can off load the waster.

Not quite what I was suggesting but I do hope he plays well for benefit of the team. He won’t make much money for us so perhaps he can fit Silva’s system.

You have quite a pessimistic outlook there chappie.

 

[Billysgingham.]

Not quite what I was suggesting but I do hope he plays well for benefit of the team. He won’t make much money for us so perhaps he can fit Silva’s system.

You have quite a pessimistic outlook there chappie.

What's pessimistic about wanting him sold?

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Not quite what I was suggesting but I do hope he plays well for benefit of the team. He won’t make much money for us so perhaps he can fit Silva’s system.

You have quite a pessimistic outlook there chappie.

He has a good point though, as much as McCarthy can add everything you’ve said; we have wasted so much money on him. He’ll no doubt be injured again soon, best to sell once he’s fit if someone comes in for him.

 

[Frang]

There’s rumours he’s playing on Saturday.

With him being willing to do the side’s dirty work, he may just be the answer to Silva’s preferred 4-3-3 (where Morgan Schneiderlin is too lazy).

Ok not a long term fix but he could fill that “number 6” roll that Silva’s said his system required but we missed out on in summer.

It will take him till the start of next season to get match fit. No way he starts Saturday. Needs to be eased back in, minutes at a time after such an injury

 

[Groucho]

What's pessimistic about wanting him sold?

He may turn out to be good again.

 

[Groucho]

He has a good point though, as much as McCarthy can add everything you’ve said; we have wasted so much money on him. He’ll no doubt be injured again soon, best to sell once he’s fit if someone comes in for him.

Have we wasted money? He cost relativley little in today’s terms and his wages will have been covered by insurance while injured.

 

[marsh]

He may turn out to be good again.

For about 20minutes maybe

 

[Billysgingham.]

He may turn out to be good again.

Nope.

 

[Groucho]

Nope.

Ok

 

[Frang]

He may turn out to be good again.

Please see Seamus Coleman as case in point.

Horrendous injury, out for 12 months or more, being over 27 ... don't bode well

 

[Groucho]

Please see Seamus Coleman as case in point.

Horrendous injury, out for 12 months or more, being over 27 ... don't bode well

Yes that possible. Also possible he may fit into Silva’s system.

To be honest I forgot he was still here.